Finding non-fluorinated alternatives to fluorinated gases used as refrigerants

Juliane Glüge,Katharina Breuer,Armin Hafner,Christian Vering,Dirk Müller,Ian T. Cousins,Rainer Lohmann,Gretta Goldenman,Martin Scheringer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-kkjwj
2024-07-24
Abstract:Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) and so-called hydrofluoroolefins (HFOs) are used as refrigerants in air conditioning, refrigeration, chillers, heat pumps and devices for dehumidification and drying. However, many HFCs, including R-134a and R-125, have a high global warming potential and some of the HFCs and HFOs degrade atmospherically and form persistent degradation products. Thus, there is an urgent need to replace fluorinated refrigerants with non-fluorinated working fluids to avoid direct emissions due to leakage, incorrect loading or removal. It is important, however, also to select refrigerants with high efficiencies to avoid indirect CO2 emissions due to a (too) high energy consumption during the use phase. The present study investigates the available non-fluorinated alternatives to fluorinated refrigerants and shows that a transition to non-fluorinated refrigerants, in general, is possible and has happened in many sectors already. Technically, there are only slight barriers to overcome to replace fluorinated refrigerants in almost all newly developed systems conforming to existing standards. Additionally, we show that alternatives are available even for some use cases for which derogations have been proposed in the PFAS restriction proposal and suggest making these derogations more specific to support bringing the use of non-fluorinated refrigerants into practice.
Chemistry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address the environmental and health issues associated with fluorinated gases as refrigerants and to explore the feasibility and application of non-fluorinated alternatives. Specifically: 1. **High Global Warming Potential (GWP)**: Many fluorinated refrigerants (such as hydrofluorocarbons HFCs and hydrofluoroolefins HFOs) have very high global warming potential, prompting the search for non-fluorinated alternatives with low GWP. 2. **Persistent Degradation Products**: Certain HFCs and HFOs decompose in the atmosphere to produce persistent substances, such as trifluoroacetic acid (TFA), which are difficult to remove and harmful to the environment. 3. **Existing Regulatory Restrictions**: The EU F-gas regulations are phasing out high GWP fluorinated refrigerants and plan to further restrict HFOs and HFCs that may form TFA. Therefore, researching non-fluorinated alternatives has become an urgent need. The paper explores existing non-fluorinated refrigerants (such as propane, isobutane, ammonia, water, carbon dioxide, etc.), demonstrating that these alternatives are not only technically feasible but have also been successfully applied in many fields. Additionally, the paper emphasizes the importance of selecting high-efficiency non-fluorinated refrigerants to reduce indirect carbon dioxide emissions.