Abstract:Introduction In the current background of global economic slowdown, the traditional reliance on one regulatory instrument or the unilateral consideration of the effectiveness of one regulatory policy in policy formulation is no longer sufficient to cope with the increasingly complex contradictions between environmental protection and economic development. In the construction of a modernized environmental governance system, it has become an inevitable choice to achieve synergy between various environmental regulations. In China, the citizens' environmental supervision campaign that gradually emerged in 2006 and the local carbon trading pilots that started in 2013, as typical representatives of informal and formal environmental regulation respectively, provide vivid and realistic materials for our study. Methods Using econometric models and microdata from listed Chinese firms from 2009 to 2020, we analyze the profound logic and internal mechanism by which this synergistic governance effect of environmental regulation affects the economic society and the development pattern of firms. Results and discussion The study found that: (1) the synergistic effect of the carbon trading policy and citizens' environmental supervision can significantly promote the transition of enterprises to a sustainable development model, especially paying attention to the role of citizens' environmental supervision in this process. (2) The regional development level, cost transfer capability, and political connection can make the synergy of the two environmental regulations vary across firms. (3) The synergistic effect of environmental regulation promotes the behavior of enterprises in line with the requirements of sustainable development by influencing enterprises' R&D and innovation investment, resource allocation efficiency, and sustainable development awareness. (4) A favorable regional rule of law environment and moderate media attention can effectively increase the intensity of citizens' environmental supervision, and at the same time strengthen the effectiveness of synergistic governance of environmental regulation in the transformation and development of enterprises.

The sword of damocles: Understanding the carbon abatement effects of top-down environmental management practices -- insights from China's campaign-style governance

The Effects of Up-down Political Inspection on Bottom-up Public Complaints in China

Could campaign-style enforcement improve environmental performance? Evidence from China's central environmental protection inspection

Top-down or bottom-up? Government Policies, Public Awareness and Carbon Reduction

The impact of campaign-style enforcement on corporate environmental Action : Evidence from China's central environmental protection inspection

Impacts and mechanisms of heterogeneous environmental regulations on carbon emissions: An empirical research based on DID method

Command thy blessing from above: vertically delegated carbon reduction targets and firm export performance in China

Can low carbon policies achieve collaborative governance of air pollution? Evidence from China's carbon emissions trading scheme pilot policy

Political Sensitivity and Carbon Emissions: Evidence From a Quasi-Natural Experiment of Leadership Change in China

The carbon emission reduction effect of auditing outgoing officials' natural resource asset management--Evidence from China

How does the low-carbon city pilot policy affect the synergistic governance efficiency of carbon and smog? Quasi-experimental evidence from China

Governmental Inspection and Local Legislation on Environmental Protection: Evidence from China

Implementation of a Multi-Agent Carbon Emission Reduction Strategy under the Chinese Dual Governance System: An Evolutionary Game Theoretical Approach

The effectiveness of dual regulation and synergistic governance of market-incentivized carbon reduction policies and public environmental supervision: a study based on the sustainable development performance of listed companies in China

Cutting ties with local bureaucrats: How does the environmental vertical management reform affect firm pollution in China?

The Impact of Environmental Regulations on Enterprise Pollution Emission from the Perspective of "Overseeing the Government"

Low-carbon governance, fiscal decentralization and sulfur dioxide emissions: Evidence from a quasi-experiment with Chinese heavy pollution enterprises

Corporate Environmental Governance Strategies Under the Dual Supervision of the Government and the Public

Low-Carbon City Construction and Corporate Carbon Reduction Performance: Evidence From a Quasi-Natural Experiment in China

Carbon mitigation performance of top-down administrative and fiscal decentralizations: Evidence from quasi-natural experiments in China's pilot counties

Evaluating the Impact of Low-Carbon Urban Policy on Corporate Green Innovation—Evidence from China's National Low-Carbon City Strategy Program