Abstract:We study 944 shareholder proposals submitted to 343 U.S. firms on climate change issues during 2009–2022. We use logistic and two-stage regression to estimate the propensity for a firm to be targeted or subjected to a vote at the annual general meeting and, for voted proposals, the determinants of that vote. We also examine whether climate-related proposals affect investor returns and how they relate to firms' future environmental performance and greenhouse gas emissions. Compared to a matched sample, we first find that activists target larger, more carbon-intensive, and less R&D-active firms. Second, voting likelihood is higher for firms with repeated and operations-related proposals and lower pre-proposal environmental ratings. By contrast, disclosure-related proposals are likelier to be negotiated and withdrawn. Third, repeated and operations-related proposals receive higher votes in favor, whereas votes on carbon-intensive firms do not. Fourth, building on the theory that investors act as if they distinguish among the different shareholder proposals based on the expected cost to the firm, we find evidence to support this idea. We find that investors respond negatively to ex-ante costlier proposals, such as those that relate to emissions reduction and target carbon-intensive firms. Fifth, targets' future environmental performance rating is almost twenty percent higher after a proposal than before compared to the matched sample, whereas emissions do not budge appreciably.

Uncertainty, Information, and Shareholder Democracy: Evidence from Voting on Shareholder Proposals

Managerial Response Under Shareholder Empowerment: Evidence from Majority Voting Legislation Changes

Shareholder Monitoring through Voting: New Evidence from Proxy Contests

Uncertainty and Corporate R&D Investment: Evidence from Chinese Listed Firms

The effect of shareholder activism on earnings management: Evidence from shareholder proposals1

Shareholder Voting and COVID-19: The China Experience

Economic Policy Uncertainty and Stock Liquidity: The Mitigating Effect of Information Disclosure.

Shareholder Voting: A Complementary Mechanism to Mandatory Disclosure Regulation

Shareholder Activism on Climate Change: Evolution, Determinants, and Consequences

The Role of Passive Investors in Corporate Governance and Socially Responsible Investing: Evidence from Shareholder Proposals

Environmental, Social, and Governance Information Rating and Firm Uncertainty Perception, Evidence from China Listed Firms

The threat of voiced shareholder disapproval and the value of voting

Uncertainty Spillovers and Share of Equity Sought in Outbound Cross-Border Acquisitions

Governance by One-Lot Shares

Political/Policy Uncertainty, Corporate Disclosure, and Information Asymmetry

The Effect of Shareholder-Initiated Corporate Governance on Accrual-Based and Real Earnings Management

Corporate Environmental, Social, and Governance Performance under Economic Policy Uncertainty: International Evidence

Community social capital, managerial opportunistic behavior, and information uncertainty in IPO firms

Investor attention and corporate leverage manipulation

Uncertainty Shocks and Corporate Policies

Political uncertainty and A-H share premium