Optimal Utilisation of Storage Systems in Transmission and Distribution Systems
C. Y. Chung,Fushuan Wen,Gerard Ledwich,Bala Venkatesh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1049/iet-gtd.2016.0114
2016-01-01
IET Generation Transmission & Distribution
Abstract:Storage systems have been used in power systems for decades. In recent years, their role in transmission and distribution systems has become more critical than ever before because of the growing penetration of intermittent renewable energy sources. While storage systems offer tremendous flexibility, they also entail challenges such as the diverse characteristics of various types and forms. Costs and benefits largely depend upon specific applications which can vary from community-aggregated energy storage such as electric vehicles to large energy storage such as pumped-storage power stations. Optimal usage of various types of storage systems to ensure maximum benefits with minimum costs has obviously become a subject that needs research and deliberation. This special issue is intended to gather high-quality and up-to-date research works that are expected to become major points of reference in this field. Thirty technical papers that address a wide range of key issues and challenges in the existing storage systems are presented in this issue and they can be categorised into five areas as follows: Clegg and Mancarella's paper entitled “Storing renewables in the gas network: modelling of power-to-gas seasonal storage flexibility in low-carbon power systems” proposes an integrated electricity-gas transmission network model with power-to-gas technology adopted for applications with long-term seasonal storage in the gas network. The capability of the proposed model has been illustrated based on Great Britain's gas and electrical networks and the National Grid's future scenarios. Tenfen, Finardi, Delinchant and Wurtz's paper “Lithium-ion battery modelling for the energy management problem of microgrids” presents a mathematical model of lithium-ion batteries in the energy management problem of a microgrid. The detailed model of lithium-ion batteries can consider the degradation cost associated with operation, controllable and uncontrollable charging ramps, other limits, and the operating characteristics provided by the manufactures. Trovato, Tindemans and Strbac's paper “Leaky storage model for optimal multi-service allocation of thermostatic loads” introduces a high-level description of the aggregate flexibility of thermostatically controlled loads as a dissipative storage unit: the leaky storage model demonstrates that clustering of appliances with similar capabilities can significantly enhance the flexibility available to the system. Kargarian and Hug's paper entitled “Optimal sizing of energy storage systems: a combination of hourly and intra-hour time perspectives” considers a planning problem that is divided into two time perspectives: hourly and intra-hour intervals. The algorithm determines the optimal size of the energy storage devices to provide the adequate ramping capability for the system in the intra-hour time horizon, and also determines a sufficient generation capacity to support the loads in the hourly time scale. Xiao, Zhang, Bai and Liang have written a paper entitled “Determination of the optimal installation site and capacity of battery energy storage system in distribution network integrated with distributed generation”. They propose a bi-level optimisation model to determine the optimal installation site and the optimal capacity of a battery energy storage system in a distribution network to accommodate the integration of distributed generation. Guo, Yu, Wang, Li, Schiettekatte, Deslauriers and Bai's paper “Optimal design of battery energy storage system for a wind–diesel off-grid power system in a remote Canadian community” focuses on the design issue of a battery energy storage system for a wind–diesel off-grid power system located in the Whapmagoostui community in Quebec, Canada. Abbasi and Hosseini have written a paper entitled “Optimal DG allocation and sizing in presence of storage systems considering network configuration effects in distribution systems” where they study distribution system reconfiguration with constant loads for optimal distributed generation allocation and sizing problems to find an optimal condition for distribution networks based on operational thresholds and reliability improvements. Sharma, Bhattacharjee and Bhattacharya's paper “Grey wolf optimisation for optimal sizing of battery energy storage device to minimise operation cost of micro-grid” reports a cost-based formulation to determine the optimal size of battery energy storage in the operation cost minimisation problem of micro-grid under various constraints, such as power capacity of distributed generators, power and energy capacity of battery energy storage systems, charge/discharge efficiency of battery energy storage systems, operating reserve and load demand satisfaction using grey wolf optimisation. Xing, Cheng, Zhang and Zeng have written a paper entitled “Active distribution network expansion planning integrating dispersed energy storage systems” that proposes a convex model for active distribution network expansion planning integrating dispersed energy storage systems with four active management schemes, which are distributed generation curtailment, demand side management, on-load tap changer tap adjustment and reactive power compensation. Zidar, Georgilakis, Hatziargyriou, Capuder and Škrlec have written a review paper entitled “Review of energy storage allocation in power distribution networks: applications, methods and future research” that provides a comprehensive overview of the current research on energy storage systems allocation, giving a unique insight into issues and challenges of integrating energy storage systems into distribution networks, and thus giving framework guidelines for future energy storage systems research. Storage systems will be making a major influence on the operation and costs of power system operation. In the section on power system operation we have storage used to affect the operation of wind fault levels. The paper by Guo, Xiao and Dai, “Fault current limiter-battery energy storage system for the doubly-fed induction generator: analysis and experimental verification”, shows how to address both stability and the low voltage ride through of wind farms. The dispatch and control of wind farms is addressed in a paper by Nguyen and Lee, “Effective power dispatch capability decision method for a wind-battery hybrid power system”, where the stored energy can help correct power fluctuations. The paper “Optimal active power control of a wind farm equipped with energy storage system based on distributed model predictive control” by Zhao, Wu, Guo, Sun and Xue shows how to correct wind power variations with better predictions of variations. Storage has a major role in the operation and control of microgrids in papers by Gabbar and Othman, and by Lan, Guan and Wu. In these papers entitled “Performance optimisation for novel green plug-energy economiser in micro-grids based on recent heuristic algorithm” and “Rollout strategies for real-time multi-energy scheduling in microgrid with storage system”, the storage is able to help manage the balance of power in a microgrid. There are several papers on the ways of better managing a power system by providing flexibility at the system level. The paper by Devlin, Li, Higgins and Foley, “System flexibility provision using short term grid scale storage”, addresses the system level utilisation of batteries to affect the ramp rate required of other generators in a system. A more conceptual approach of local storage meeting local demand is examined by Zhou and Littler in “Local storage meets local demand: a technical solution to future power distribution system”, which shows how the system wide variability can be reduced by having local storage acting to limit system level variability. One of the new factors raised in the paper by Zhou, Liu, Cao, Li, Chung, and Chan, “Optimal scheduling of virtual power plant with battery degradation cost”, is that there will be degradation of batteries dependent on the way they are used. The paper makes the degradation cost an explicit part of scheduling optimisation. The benefits to owners of storage can come from coordinated control considering both owner and network aspects as illustrated by Miranda, Liete and Silva in “Coordination of multifunctional distributed energy storage systems in distribution networks”. Choi, Heo and Kim's paper “Hybrid operation strategy of wind energy storage system for power grid frequency regulation” presents a hybrid operation strategy using a battery energy storage system and a wind energy conversion system for active power and frequency control. The proposed operation scheme is validated to successfully improve the frequency regulation capability of the power system. Nezamabadi and Nazar's paper entitled “Arbitrage strategy of virtual power plants in energy, spinning reserve and reactive power markets” integrates the distributed energy resources into the concept of virtual power plants to interact with electricity markets and power system operators, and an arbitrage strategy is proposed for the market participants of virtual power plants. The arbitrage opportunities for virtual power plants are discovered with simultaneous optimisation of energy and ancillary service markets. Sebastián's paper “Application of a battery energy storage for frequency regulation and peak shaving in a wind diesel power system” models a power system with diesel generators, wind turbines, loads and battery energy storage systems. Simulation results demonstrate the contributions of battery energy storage systems in regulating the system frequency, improving the power quality and peak shaving applications. Sun, Wang, Liu, Lin, Wen, Ang and Salam's paper entitled “Optimisation model for power system restoration with support from electric vehicles employing battery swapping” proposes to employ the batteries of electric vehicles with the battery swapping mode for providing starting power for generators after blackouts or local power outages. The idle electric vehicle batteries and centralised charging stations are able to act as power sources and effectively restore a power system with insufficient black-start capacity. Vidyanandan and Senroy's paper “Frequency regulation in a wind-diesel powered microgrid using flywheels and fuel cells” develops a control strategy for the frequency regulation of a microgrid with diesel generators, wind power, and storages of fuel cells and flywheels. The energy storages enhance the reliability of the microgrid and the efficiency of diesel generators with the proposed control strategy. Majumder and Khaparde's paper entitled “Revenue and ancillary benefit maximisation of multiple non-collocated wind power producers considering uncertainties” formulates the participation of wind power producers with multiple wind turbine generators and battery storage devices in a forward day-ahead electricity market. The cooperative scheduling generally leads to higher social benefit of all wind power producers, while the maximised individual profit is achieved through independent operation. Dunbar, Cradden, Wallace and Harrison's paper “Impact of wind power on arbitrage revenue for electricity storage” investigates the arbitrage opportunities of electrical energy storage based on the variations in the gas price, electricity price and daily demand in Great Britain. Simulation results indicate that the increasing capacities of wind power change the characteristics of electricity price volatility, which may reduce the revenue and increase the risk of energy storage operation and investment. Thapa and Karki's paper entitled “Reliability benefit of energy storage in wind integrated power system operation” presents a probabilistic method to assess the reliability contribution of energy storage using two probabilistic indices: the wind power commitment risk and the unit commitment risk. The numerical results provide an insight on the reliability benefits of employing an appropriate energy storage system in conjunction with a wind farm. Mateo, Reneses, Rodriguez-Calvo, Frías and Sánchez's paper entitled “Cost-benefit analysis of battery storage in medium-voltage distribution networks” addresses the distributed use of battery storage in medium-voltage distribution networks. The work presented in this paper can help understand the business case behind the use of storage located at secondary substations to perform peak shaving, the main aspects involved and the circumstances that could make it indeed profitable for the distribution system. Maghouli, Soroudi and Keane's paper on “Robust computational framework for mid-term techno-economical assessment of energy storage” presents an approach for assessing grid-scale energy storage devices deployment in a power system based on the information gap decision theory for handling wind generation uncertainty. The applicability and performance of the proposed method in mid-term robust evaluation of energy storage implementation plans are demonstrated by a modified IEEE reliability test system and a modified IEEE-118-bus test system. Hayes, Wilson, Webster and Djokic's paper entitled “Comparison of two energy storage options for optimum balancing of wind farm power outputs” evaluates the feasibility of combining wind-based generation technologies with two energy storage schemes: a conventional pumped storage hydro scheme of a smaller size, and an inverter-interfaced battery energy storage systems scheme of a larger size. The analysis is carried out using a case study of balancing outputs and maximising benefits for both an existing wind farm, for which measured data are available, and for several theoretical study cases. As guest editors of this special issue, we thank the authors of the high quality papers and the reviewers who provided their strong supports in the reviewing process and ensuring the quality of the papers. We also express our deep gratitude to Professor Innocent Kamwa and Professor Christian Rehtanz for entrusting us with organising this special issue. C. Y. Chung is a Professor, the NSERC/SaskPower Industrial Research Chair in Smart Grid Technologies and the SaskPower Chair in Power Systems Engineering in the Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering at the University of Saskatchewan, Canada. He is a Member-at-Large (Smart Grid) of the IEEE PES Governing Board. He is also a Fellow of IEEE and IET. Fushuan Wen has been a Full Professor and the Director of the Institute of Power Economics and Information in Zhejiang University (China) since 1997. He is currently a Professor in Brunei University of Technology, taking leave from Zhejiang University. He is an Associate Editor of IET Generation, Transmission and Distribution, and ASCE's Journal of Energy Engineering. Gerard Ledwich is a professor in Electrical Power Engineering at Queensland University of Technology (QUT) and Fellow of the Institution of Engineers Australia. His current position is Chair in Power Engineering at Queensland University of Technology. His research interests include control systems, power electronics, power systems, condition monitoring and distributed generation. He is on the editorial panel of IET Transaction on Power Electronics and Journal of Modern Power Systems and Clean Energy. Bala Venkatesh is a Professor and Director of the Centre for Urban Energy, Ryerson University, Canada. In addition, he heads the Canadian NSERC Energy Storage Technology Network.