A Study of the Relationships between Employee Voice and Employee Silence: A Nomological Network Perspective
Duan Jinyun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2012.04.009
2012-01-01
Abstract:As two representative discretionary work behaviors(DWBs),the research on voice behavior and on employee silence go their own way all along,the empirical studies on their relationships are under development.Employee voice and employee silence seem like opposite constructs,but their real relation are not as superficial as they show.To explore this question,based on nomological network,the study testifies the relationships between voice behavior and employee silence,from affect,cognition and leadership perspective.The sample was taken from private firms and foreign capital firms which locate in the Yangtze River Delta.To alleviate the common method variance,the data was taken from the matched sample of subordinate and supervisor.Namely,the dependent variables were rated by supervisors(excluding employee silence because it is an unobservable phenomenon) and the independent variables were measured by subordinates.Later on,350 subordinatesupervisor valid dyads were used to analyze the hypotheses.Using SPSS and AMOS software,the analyses procedures include confirmatory factor analysis(CFA),descriptive statistic analysis,exploratory factor analysis(EFA),regression analysis and structured equation modeling(SEM).The findings include: Voice behavior and employee silence are two independent constructs and they are not significantly related.In the affect characteristics,positive affect can advance employee voice;negative affect can increase both voice behavior and employee silence.In the cognitive characteristics,self-efficacy are positively related to voice behavior,psychological safety are positively related to voice behavior,and negatively related to employee silence.In the leadership characteristic,leader-member exchange(LMX) can boost voice behavior,but its impact on employee silence is not significant.For their consequence,employee voice is more welcome to supervisor than employee silence.