An explanation for the Rule of Four in Inorganic Materials

Robert Palgrave

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv-2024-sxqwh

2024-04-23

Abstract:Recently, Gazzarrini et al. observed a ‘rule of four’, where the number of atoms in a primitive unit cell for inorganic materials taken from large databases has been observed to favour multiples of four.1 The number of atoms in a primitive cell is given by the product of the number of atoms in a formula unit (nF) and the number of formula units per primitive cell (Z). Here it is shown the rule of four can be explained by taking into account the most probable values of nF and Z in inorganic materials datasets.

Chemistry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to explain the "Rule of Four" (RoF) phenomenon in inorganic materials. Specifically, Gazzarrini et al. observed in a large inorganic materials database that the number of atoms in the primitive unit cell tends to be a multiple of 4. The authors of this paper explore the reasons behind this phenomenon by analyzing data from the inorganic materials database.

The authors point out that the number of atoms \( A \) in the primitive unit cell can be expressed as the product of the number of atoms \( n_F \) in the chemical formula unit and the number of formula units \( Z \) per primitive unit cell: \( A = n_F \times Z \). To understand the RoF phenomenon, the authors studied the distribution of \( n_F \) and \( Z \) in different databases.

1. **Distribution of \( n_F \)**:
- In the Materials Project database, the most common \( n_F \) value is 4 (accounting for 14.6% of all entries). The overall distribution shows a skewed normal distribution or a superposition of two different distributions.
- There is no obvious preference for multiples of 4 or even numbers, which may be due to sampling bias.

2. **Distribution of \( Z \)**:
- In the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database (ICSD), the most common value of \( Z \) is 4 (accounting for 34% of the primitive structures), followed by 2 and 1, while 3 and 5 are very rare.
- A common way to increase \( Z \) is by modulating the ideal structure, such as positional modulation or compositional modulation along one direction, which usually doubles \( Z \) or \( n_F \).

By combining the distributions of \( n_F \) and \( Z \), the authors found that when \( Z \) is 2 or 4, and \( n_F \) is not particularly large, the number of atoms \( A \) in the primitive unit cell is very likely to be a multiple of 4. This combination explains the RoF phenomenon and is consistent with the previous observations by Gazzarrini et al.