Abstract:Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of six upgraded empirical force fields were compared and evaluated with short peptides, intrinsically disordered proteins, and folded proteins using trajectories of 1, 1.5, 5, or 10 μs (five replicates of 200 ns, 300 ns, 1 μs, or 2 μs) for each system. Previous studies have shown that different force fields, water models, simulation methods, and parameters can affect simulation outcomes. Here, the MD simulations were done in an explicit solvent with RS-peptide, HEWL19, HIV-rev, β amyloid (Aβ)-40, Aβ-42, phosphodiesterase-γ, CspTm, and ubiquitin using ff99IDPs, ff14IDPs, ff14IDPSFF, ff03w, CHARMM36m, and CHARMM22* force fields. The IDP ensembles generated by six all-atom empirical force fields were compared against NMR data. Despite using identical starting structures and simulation parameters, ensembles obtained with different force fields exhibit significant differences in NMR RMDs, secondary structure contents, and global properties such as the radius of gyration. The intrinsically disordered protein (IDP)-specific force fields could substantially reproduce the experimental observables in force field comparison: they have the lowest error in chemical shifts and J-couplings for short peptides/proteins, reasonably well for large IDPs and reasonably well with the radius of gyration. A high population of disorderness was observed in the IDP-specific force field for the IDP ensemble with a fraction of β sheets for β-amyloids. CHARMM22* performs better for many observables; however, it still has a preference toward the helicity for short peptides. The results of β-amyloid 42 starting from two different initial structures (Aβ421Z0Q and Aβ42model) were also compared with DSSP and NMR data. The results obtained with IDP-specific force fields within 2 μs simulation time are similar, even though starting from different structures. The current force fields perform equally well for folded proteins. The results of currently developed or modified force fields for IDPs are capable of enlightening the overall performance of the force field for disordered as well as folded proteins, thereby contributing to force field development.The Supporting Information is available free of charge at <a class="ext-link" href="/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.0c00762?goto=supporting-info">https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.0c00762</a>.Predicted measurement comparison (Table S1); secondary chemical shift conversion (Figure S1); time evolution of the cumulative Rg and the end-to-end distance (Figure S2); comparison of secondary chemical shifts between MD simulations and NMR experiments (Figure S3); cluster analyses (Figure S4); calculated NMR observables in simulations of Ab40 starting from the PDB structure and the extended structure (Figure S5); secondary structure propensity analysis of the trajectories (Figure S6); RMSD analyses of all of the trajectories under the tested force fields (Figure S7) (<a class="ext-link" href="/doi/suppl/10.1021/acs.jcim.0c00762/suppl_file/ci0c00762_si_001.pdf">PDF</a>)This article has not yet been cited by other publications.

An Evaluation of Force Field Accuracy for the Mini-Protein Chignolin using Markov State Models

Learning Effective Molecular Models from Experimental Observables.

AIMD-Chig: Exploring the conformational space of a 166-atom protein Chignolin with ab initio molecular dynamics

Systematic Validation of Protein Force Fields against Experimental Data

A Test of AMBER Force Fields in Predicting the Secondary Structure of Α-Helical and Β-Hairpin Peptides

Comparison and Evaluation of Force Fields for Intrinsically Disordered Proteins

Exploring the Binding Mechanism Between Human Profilin (PFN1) and Polyproline-10 Through Binding Mode Screening

Improved Estimates of Folding Stabilities and Kinetics with Multiensemble Markov Models

Coupled Two-Dimensional Main-Chain Torsional Potential for Protein Dynamics II: Performance and Validation.

Evaluating force field accuracy with long-time simulations of a tryptophan zipper peptide

Towards a Benchmark for Markov State Models: The Folding of HP35

Consistent View of Protein Fluctuations from All-Atom Molecular Dynamics and Coarse-Grained Dynamics with Knowledge-Based Force-Field.

Accelerated Molecular Dynamics for Peptide Folding: Benchmarking Different Combinations of Force Fields and Explicit Solvent Models

Ab initio folding of Chignolins by replica-exchange molecular dynamics simulations

Toward a general neural network force field for protein simulations: Refining the intramolecular interaction in protein

Folding Simulations for Proteins with Diverse Topologies Are Accessible in Days with A Physics-Based Force Field and Implicit Solvent

Tmff-A Two-Bead Multipole Force Field for Coarse-Grained Molecular Dynamics Simulation of Protein

Simulation of the thermodynamics of folding and unfolding of the Trp-cage mini-protein TC5b using different combinations of force fields and solvation models

Developing a molecular dynamics force field for both folded and disordered protein states

Simulating the Peptide Folding Kinetic Related Spectra Based on the Markov State Model

Toward a predictive understanding of slow methyl group dynamics in proteins.