Conflict in Translaboration: Contract, Ideology, and Translation Strategy
Yun-fang Dai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07374836.2024.2402900
2024-10-11
Translation Review
Abstract:No potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s). 1. Alfer, "Entering the Translab," 288. 2. Dai, "Power Imbalance in Translaboration." 3. Drugan, "Complex Collaborations," for example. 4. Yang, "Participatory, Self-Organising, and Learning"; and Santos and Jones, "Creativity in Collaborative Poetry Translating." 5. Among others, Cordingley and Manning, "What is Collaborative Translation," 15; and Santos and Jones, "Creativity in Collaborative Poetry Translating," 283. 6. Jiang, "Contemporary Chinese Women Writers," 27. The notion of "agent" has various definitions. This article refers to the usage adopted by John Milton and Paul Bandia who use the definition of agent coined by Juan Sager. Sager describes the agent as a person "in an intermediary position between a translator and an end user of a translation," and expands it to include translators, see Milton and Bandia, "Introduction: Agents," 1. The main difference between the notions of "agent" and "stakeholder" lies in whether the participants who passively take part in the process are included, for example the authors and the readers. 7. Zwischenberger, "Translaboration," 179. 8. Gray, Collaborating , 4–5; and further developed in Wood and Gray, "Toward a Comprehensive Theory," 146. 9. Wood and Gray, "Toward a Comprehensive Theory," 146. 10. Heller, "Translaboration as Legitimation." 11. Dai, "Power Imbalance in Translaboration," 610. 12. Gray, Collaborating , 5; reiterated in Wood and Gray, "Toward a Comprehensive Theory," 143; and cited in Zwischenberger, "Translaboration," 178–79. 13. Gray, Collaborating , 9. 14. See Smith, "Edward Garnett," 311. 15. Baker, Translation and Conflict , 1. 16. Zwischenberger, "Translaboration," 181. 17. Rędzioch-Korkuz, "Intimacy in the Strict Sense," 90. 18. Gray, Collaborating , 6. 19. Pym, "Cooperation, Risk, Trust," 10–11. It is important to note that in Organization Theory, the term "cooperation," characterized by its informality, is distinguished from collaboration based on "whether individual agency or collective goals are emphasized, on the extent to which power is centralized, and on the degree of formalized decision rules," see Gray, Collaborating , 242. 20. Rędzioch-Korkuz, "Intimacy in the Strict Sense," 90. 21. Ibid., 95. 22. Admittedly, if we take into the consideration the stakeholders who provide a freelance translation service, commercial gain might appear less attractive. 23. Chesterman, Memes of Translation , 61, 73; and Pym, "Cooperation, Risk, Trust," 9. 24. In some cases, the literary agents, who represent authors and offer their works to publishers, play the role of client. They initiate a translation project by selecting the book to be translated, pitching to publishers, and recommending co-translators, as described in Hong Diao's research on Anna Holmwood's literary agenting of Legends of the Condor Heroes , the translation of Jin Yong's Shediao yingxiongzhuan . See Diao, "Translating and Literary Agenting." 25. Bush, "Translating Anglophone African Literature," 516. 26. Qi, "Piracy and the Commodification," 57. 27. Ibid. 28. Venuti, The Scandals of Translation , 151. 29. Katan, "Occupation or Profession," 200. 30. Dam and Zethsen, "Translator Status," 200. 31. Emmerich, Literary Translation and the Making of Originals , 3. 32. Ibid., 6. 33. Ibid., 7. Similarly, The Dark Forest was revised by the author partly according to the comments made by the English translator, Joel Martinsen. See Deng and Goh, "An interview with Joel Martinsen," 88. 34. See note 30 above. 35. Gray, Collaborating , 64–65. 36. Munday, "Translation and Ideology," 197. 37. Wu, "A Sociological Study of Howard," 318–25. 38. Ibid., 327. 39. Stalling, "The Voice of the Translator," 7. 40. Ibid., 8. 41. Madueke, "Translating Across the Imperial Divide," 275. 42. Ibid., 270. 43. Ibid., 273. 44. Saadat, "Translaboration," 354–65. 45. Davison, Translation as Collaboration , 6. 46. Ibid., 12. 47. Ibid., 9. 48. Ibid., 115. 49. Ibid., 120. 50. Deng and Goh, "An Interview with Joel Martinsen," 90. 51. Ibid., 86. 52. Ibid. One of the reasons for the editor's decision to add extensive footnotes was to achieve the consistency to the style of the translations of the other two books in the series, namely Ken Liu's translations of The Three-Body Problem and Death's End , see Deng and Goh, "An interview with Joel Martinsen," 86. 53. Bollettieri and Zanotti, "The Avant-Textes of Translations," 10. 54. Ibid., 7. 55. Yao, "Author as the Other Translator," 132 and 133. 56. Ibid., 136–137. 57. Stalling, "The Voice of the Translator," 5. 58. Ibid. 59. Ibid., 201. 60. Ibid., 201, 209. 61. Ibid., 209. 62. Ibid. 63. Yao, "Author as the Other Translator," 133. 64. Sela-Sheffy, "How to Be a (Recognized) Translator," 4–5. 65. Dam and Zethsen, "Translator Status," 207. 66. Daldeniz, "Islamic Publ -Abstract Truncated-