On Restitution Emerging from Invalidity of Legal Act

Yin Tian
2010-01-01
Abstract:After a legal act has been recognized as invalid,both parties should return mutually all those prestations they have received from each other if they can.Nevertheless,if it is objectively can not be returned for one side's prestation,to handle logically and fairly in light of general principle becomes unrealistic,the only way to solve must be handling differently according to the varied invalidities.So after a relatively invalid legal act has been revoked,the interests of the party assuming the right of revocation must be given enough consideration,and the principle,handling those invalid acts just like they are valid,which has been adopted by our judicial practice on cost determination relating to some kinds of executed absolutely invalid acts,is somewhat reasonable.In addition,a clear line should be drawn between civil restitution and administrative penalty.As for invalid donation violating public order and good custom,principles dealing with invalid bilateral contract ought to be referred,that is,those remained not performed yet can not be requested,but the donator who has prestated can not ask for restitution.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?