The Legal Logic after the Reconciliation in Second Instance:Reviewing the First Batch of Guide Cases of the “Wumei Case”

Yan Renqun

2012-01-01

Abstract:Plaintiff also can recall his claim with the consent of defendant in second instance.If judgment has not being restricted,it must be enforced according to the application.The settlement agreement after standard time of res judicata,can change creditor's rights determined by court,but cannot restrict its enforcement power,court should does so based on the application.Settlement agreement's taking effect has nothing to do with breach of contract.Law has ruled about liability for breach of contract,so good faith doctrine need not be applied.Substantial dispute must be tried with substantial procedure.Being unacquainted with the above legal principle,Wumei case has seven deficiencies——illegally set out new requirement for enforcement of judgment,misunderstand the relationship between binding judgment and settlement agreement,analogize article 207th of civil procedure law,confuse recall of complaint and appeal,key point does not correspond with reason for judgment,name of the case disaccord with its issues.