A Comparative Study of Ventilation/perfusion Scintigraphy and MRPA in the Diagnosis of Pulmonary Embolism

Jincheng Wang
2007-01-01
Abstract:Objective The aim of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic value of ventilation/per- fusion(V/Q)scintigraphy in pulmonary embolism(PE)in comparison with three-dimensional(3D)mag- netic resonance pulmonary angiography(MRPA).Methods Twenty-eight patients underwent pulmonary V/Q imaging and MRPA within 3 d.There were 11 men and 17 women with mean age of(50.1±14.4) years.Among them,22 PE were confirmed by pulmonary arteriography or operation,as well as clinical fol- lowed-up after successful thrombolytic therapy.These 22 patients were divided into 3 groups:lobe,seg- ment,and subsegment lesions.In the other 6 patients,PE had been ruled out by clinical comprehensive a- nalysis and follow-up survey,including one case confirmed by pulmonary arteriography.Results In lobe group,both V/Q imaging and MRPA detected all PEs.In segment group,V/Q imaging detected 125 seg- mental pathological changes and MRPA demonstrated 139 abnormal segmental pulmonary arteries.The latter had partially overestimated,but the statistic difference was not significant(P=0.110).In subsegment group,V/Q imaging detected 84 subsegment pathological changes,whereas MRPA demonstrated 55 subseg- ment arterial damages,the statistic difference was significant between two groups.(P0.05).Conclusion MRPA and V/Q imaging are both sensitive methods for detecting lobar and segmental PE,but V/Q imaging is far better than MRPA in detecting subsegment PE.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?