Abstract:The question of whether and how digital media use and digital communication affect people’s and particularly adolescents’ well-being has been investigated for several decades. Many studies have analyzed how different forms of digital communication influence loneliness and life satisfaction, two comparatively stable cognitive indicators of subjective well-being. Despite this large body of empirical work, the findings remain ambivalent, with studies resulting in positive, negative, or nonsignificant effects. Several meta-analyses suggest that the overall effect of digital communication on life satisfaction is probably too small to suggest a detrimental effect. The net effect of digital communication on loneliness, by contrast, is positive, but likewise small. Yet the studies on which these meta-analyses are based suffer from several limitations. They often adopt a limited perspective on the phenomenon of interest as a disproportionate amount of work focuses on interpersonal differences instead of intra-individual, contextual, and situational effects, as well as their interactions. Furthermore, studies are often based on cross-sectional data, use unvalidated and imprecise measurements, and differ greatly in how they conceptualize digital communication. The diversity in studied applications and forms of digital communication also suggests that effects are most likely bidirectional. Passive digital communication (e.g., browsing and lurking) is more likely to result in negative effects on well-being. Active and purposeful digital communication (e.g., posting, liking, conversating), by contrast, is more likely to result in positive effects. Future research should therefore investigate how the various levels of digital communication (including differences in devices, applications, features, interactions, and messages) interact in shaping individuals’ well-being. Instead of expecting long-term effects on comparatively stable cognitive indicators such as life satisfaction, scholars should rather study and identify the spatial and temporal boundaries of digital communication effects on the more fluctuating affective components of well-being.

POSTS with NO RESPONSE: THE ISLAND of LONELINESS

Examining Relations Between Locus of Control, Loneliness, Subjective Well-Being, and Preference for Online Social Interaction

The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?

Examining the Public Messaging on 'Loneliness' over Social Media: An Unsupervised Machine Learning Analysis of Twitter Posts over the Past Decade

Re-Conceptualizing Solitude in the Digital Era: From “Being Alone” to “Noncommunication”

Effect of Social Loneliness on Tourist Happiness: A Mediation Analysis Based on Smartphone Usage

Many Ways to Be Lonely: Fine-Grained Characterization of Loneliness and Its Potential Changes in COVID-19

How loneliness is talked about in social media during COVID-19 pandemic: Text mining of 4,492 Twitter feeds

Head versus heart: social media reveals differential language of loneliness from depression

Study on Relationship Between Internet Use and Loneliness

Receiving feedback after posting status updates on social networking sites predicts lower loneliness: A mediated moderation model

The Effect of Consumer’s Loneliness on Impulse Buying in the Internet era: A Model Based on Para-social Interaction

How loneliness leads to the conversational AI usage intention: the roles of anthropomorphic interface, para-social interaction

The effect of internet use behaviors on loneliness: the mediating role of real-life interpersonal communication

Belonging and loneliness in cyberspace: impacts of social media on adolescents’ well-being

Loneliness and Social Internet Use: Pathways to Reconnection in a Digital World?

Digital Communication Effects on Loneliness and Life Satisfaction

The Phenomenon of Loneliness Among Young People

Alone with my phone? Examining beliefs about solitude and technology use in adolescence

Unmasking the Nuances of Loneliness: Using Digital Biomarkers to Understand Social and Emotional Loneliness in College Students

Social and Web Data Framework for Understanding Loneliness