Plough Tillage Maintains High Rice Yield and Lower Greenhouse Gas Emissions under Crop Straw Incorporation

Jun Zhang,Frederick Danso,Oluwaseyi Oyewale Bankole,Nan Zhang,Wenjun Dong,Kun Zhang,Changying Lu,Ziyin Shang,Gexing Li,Aixing Deng,Zhenwei Song,Chengyan Zheng,Weijian Zhang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4082795
2022-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:Crop straw incorporation can promote rice production while impacting methane (CH4) emissions from paddy fields. Proper management of straw returned to paddy fields for lower greenhouse gas emission (GHG) while maintaining high crop yield is of importance in rice cropping systems. Under three typical rice-based cropping systems (single rice, double rice and rice-wheat) of China, this study investigated three patterns of straw incorporation, including the treatments of reduced tillage incorporated with straw (RedT + S), rotary tillage incorporated with straw (RoT + S), plough tillage incorporated with straw (PT + S), and conventional tillage as the control (PT in Harbin, RoT for Suzhou and Jinxian). Straw incorporation pattern insignificantly affected rice yield by -6.8% ~ 3.2%, -9.1% ~ 9.0% and -9.8% ~ 2.1% in comparison to the control at Harbin, Suzhou and Jinxian, respectively. Compared to the control, the addition of crop straw, triggered 56.6% more CH4 emission from RedT + S at Harbin, and produced 45.0% and 72.1% more CH4 emission from RoT + S respectively in Jinxian and Suzhou. In the three locations, straw incorporation patterns compared to the control, increased both the area-scaled and yield-scaled emissions by 1.2 – 3.4 folds and 1.2 – 3.8 folds respectively. Among the straw retained treatments, PT + S recorded the least area and yield-scaled emissions. This study indicates that that plough tillage with straw incorporation is effective in reducing CH4 emissions, area-and yield-scaled total GHG emissions while maintaining high yield.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?