Abstract:The article proposes an account of the prevailing classical Chinese conception of reasoning and argumentation that grounds it in a semantic theory and epistemology centered on drawing distinctions (biàn ) between the similar and dissimilar kinds of things that do or do not fall within the extension of ‘names’ (míng ). The article presents two novel interpretive hypotheses. First, for pre-Hàn Chinese thinkers, the functional role associated with the logical copula is filled by a general notion of similarity or sameness (tóng ). Second, these thinkers’ basic explanation of reasoning is that it is a process of moving from a comparison of whether something is similar to a ‘model’ or ‘standard’ ( fǎ ) to a judgment about whether that thing is part of a certain kind (lèi ). Classical texts treat judgment as the attitude of predicating a ‘name’ of something, or, equivalently, of distinguishing whether something is the kind of thing denoted by a certain term. Reasoning is treated as a process of considering how some acts of term predication, or drawing distinctions, normatively commit one to making further, analogous predications or drawing further, analogous distinctions. Inference is thus understood as the act of distinguishing something as a certain kind of thing as a result of having distinguished it as similar to a relevant ‘model’ or ‘standard’. The article concludes by summarizing the consequences of the proposed account of early Chinese semantic and logical theories for the interpretation of other areas of classical Chinese thought.

On Logical Forms and Characteristics of Negative Judgment Reasoning

Local Relations Hold Reasoning

Non-monotonic Reasoning and Argumentation System

Problems of Inconsistency and Argumentation Logics

Negative Rules and Reduction in Rough Sets Based on Similarity Relation

Distinctions, Judgment, and Reasoning in Classical Chinese Thought

Reasoning in Social Settings

Toward a Hierarchal "View of Logic in Broad Sense"——Retrospection and Reflection of the Two Major Disputes on "View of Logic"

Going Forth and Drawing Back: an Intensional Approach in Nonmonotonic Inference.

Negation Effect and Logical Equivalence——An Explanation to Wason's Selection Task

A Doubting Logic System Containing Descartes Axiom

Logic and Natural Language

A Base Logic for Default Reasoning

On Non-formal Logic:Its Objects and Future Directions

A Semiotic Perspective on Logical Reasoning

Normalisation for Negative Free Logics without and with Definite Descriptions

A logic of judgmental existence and its relation to proof irrelevance

Conception and Theory of Logic——TWO Significant Factors in the Study of Chinese Logic History

On Logical Analysis of Evaluating a Real Argument in Everyday Life

On Argument Evaluation from A Perspective of Informal Logic

On Logical Foundation of Legal Argument in Criminal Trial