Abstract:In 1651 the Italian astronomer Giovanni Battista Riccioli published within his Almagestum Novum, a massive 1500 page treatise on astronomy, a discussion of 126 arguments for and against the Copernican hypothesis (49 for, 77 against). A synopsis of each argument is presented here, with discussion and analysis. Seen through Riccioli's 126 arguments, the debate over the Copernican hypothesis appears dynamic and indeed similar to more modern scientific debates. Both sides present good arguments as point and counter-point. Religious arguments play a minor role in the debate; careful, reproducible experiments a major role. To Riccioli, the anti-Copernican arguments carry the greater weight, on the basis of a few key arguments against which the Copernicans have no good response. These include arguments based on telescopic observations of stars, and on the apparent absence of what today would be called "Coriolis Effect" phenomena; both have been overlooked by the historical record (which paints a picture of the 126 arguments that little resembles them). Given the available scientific knowledge in 1651, a geo-heliocentric hypothesis clearly had real strength, but Riccioli presents it as merely the "least absurd" available model - perhaps comparable to the Standard Model in particle physics today - and not as a fully coherent theory. Riccioli's work sheds light on a fascinating piece of the history of astronomy, and highlights the competence of scientists of his time.

Heavenly Spheres",not "heavenly Bodies" ──in Memory of 460 Anniversaries of Publication of Copernicus′ on the Revolutions of Heavenly Spheres

From “supreme Oneness” (‘taiyi’) to “principle” (‘li’): A Comparison of Xing Yunlu and Wang Xichan’s Astronomy System

Setting Up Copernicus? Astronomy and Natural Philosophy in Giambattista Capuano Da Manfredonia's Expositio on the Sphere

The Search for the Harmony of Universe by Copernicus and Kepler

The Starry Universe of Johannes Kepler

126 Arguments Concerning the Motion of the Earth, as presented by Giovanni Battista Riccioli in his 1651 Almagestum Novum

Our Book Shelf

The coplanarity of planetary orbits places bounds on dynamical aether

A translation of L. Euler's "Considerations on the motion of celestial bodies"

Orbital motions of astronomical bodies and their Centre of Mass from different reference frames: a conceptual step between the Geocentric and Heliocentric models

A translation of L. Euler's "On the motion of comets in parabolic orbits, having the Sun in the focus"

Of Mites and Men: Johannes Kepler on Stars and Size

The Sphere and The Labyrinth, and Others

Telescopes and astronomy:A 400-year retrospect and future prospects

The Evolution of Geography A Sketch of the Rise and Progress of Geographical Knowledge from the Earliest Times to the First Circumnavigation of the Globe

Celestial mechanics, from high-school to Newton's Principia

Ludwik Antoni Birkenmajer and Curtis Wilson on the Origin of Nicholas Copernicus's Heliocentrism

From heliocentrism to epicycles: A commentary on pre-Ptolemaic astronomy

The Sun at the Center of the World

A Unified Nomenclature and Taxonomy for Planets, Stars, and Moons