Meta Analysis of Cervical Treatment Stage 1B and 2A Between Chemotherapy First, or Surgery First, or Surgery Followed by Radiotherapy.

Haroon Sheikh,Manhua Cui,Yang Rulin

2014-01-01

Abstract:Background: Cervical cancer is the most common gynecologic malignancy in female population of developing countries. However, the treatment of early-stage cervical cancer (IB and IIA) includes radical hysterectomy following by either chemotherapy or radiation therapy remains controversial. Aims: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the adverse effects and survival outcome of cervical cancer stage 1B and 2A treatment with 1) chemotherapy first 2) or surgery first, or 3) Surgery followed by radiotherapy. Methods: A systematic review of literature and published studies between 1974-2012 in cervical treatment stage 1B and 2A was performed, and a meta-analysis and the summary information from eligible studies was used to estimate and calculate Odd ratio (OR) and 95% confidence interval (CI). Results: After reviewing the published articles, we chose 10 studies, which were eligible for meta-analysis and fit the criteria. The average sample size was 190 patients. Meta analysis proved that for cervical cancer stage 1B and 2A the best option of treatment is radical hysterectomy with lymph nodes removal followed by radiotherapy. The Meta analysis found that of the 10 studies, 5 studies have statistically significant treatment effect. The significant odd ratios (OR) at the 5% level (P<0.05) of having a favourable outcome among the studies using radiotherapy after radical hysterectomy were 0.097 (95% CI, 0.055 - 0.1771) 1.71 (95% CI, 1.254 - 0.2.347), and 0.097 (95% CI, 0.055 - 0.1771). The narrow width of CI for these studies indicated the more precise estimates for their results. On the other hand, the significant odds ratio (OR) at the 5% level (P<0.05) of having a favourable outcome among the studies using chemotherapy plus radiotherapy after radical hysterectomy were 3.973 (95% CI, 1.934 - 8.16), and 3.973 (95% CI, 1.934 - 8.16) However, the width of CI for these studies may indicate the less precise estimates for their results. Conclusions: The best option of treatment cervical cancer stage 1B and 2A was radical hysterectomy with lymph nodes removal followed by radiotherapy. Based on our result, we recommend that postoperative radiation be considered in the management of patients with stage 1B-2A cervical carcinomas found to have regional lymph node metastases; however, alternate forms of therapy deserve consideration when the tumor extends to both the parametrium and pelvic lymph nodes.