Abstract:States are key actors in global health governance, particularly in the prevention and control of infectious diseases. The emergence and re-emergence of infectious diseases in recent decades pose profound challenges to global health security. As the first coronavirus pandemic, the COVID-19 caused significant damage worldwide, but responses and outcomes varied greatly among states. Using COVID-19 as an example, this study aims to compare the policies and measures implemented by different states during the COVID-19 pandemic and to synthesize experiences to strengthen global health governance for future infectious disease crises. We used Arksey and O'Malley's five-stage scoping review framework and PRISMA methodology was used for literature search and decision on relevant studies. English databases were searched using combinations of keywords and articles examining COVID-19 prevention and control policies in representative countries were included. A comparative analysis across these four states (United States, Sweden, India, and Nigeria) was then conducted to analyse the differences, rationale, and challenges of the approaches taken by these states. A total of 36 studies were included in the analysis. The management of the COVID-19 by states is divided into two main categories: domestic governance and international governance. Domestically, the United States and India have taken more measures, yet notable disparities in infection source control, transmission interruption, vulnerable population protection, collaborative governance, and so on were observed among all four states. Globally, the United States and Sweden were more proactive in international governance, and all four states have variations in their adherence to global regulations, information sharing, resource distribution, and cooperative engagement. Significant disparities occurred during the response to early COVID-19 in four states, which may be due to differences in politics, economy, and culture. To prevent and mitigate the impact of infectious diseases, states should, in future, prioritize solidarity and cooperation, and improve governance domestically and internationally based on national contexts and global health principles.

Learning from COVID-19: a Systems Approach for Public Health Governance

Learning From COVID-19: A Systems Approach for Public Health Governance

Urban Epidemic Governance: an Event System Analysis of the Outbreak and Control of COVID-19 in Wuhan, China

Governance Capability of the Public Health System: A Comparative Analysis of the Control of COVID-19 in the Different Provinces of China

COVID-19 in China: Responses, Challenges and Implications for the Health System

Governing public health emergencies during the coronavirus disease outbreak: Lessons from four Chinese cities in the first wave

Confronting and Governing the Public Health Emergency

From bureaucratic administration to effective intervention: Comparing early governmental responses to the COVID-19 virus across East Asian and western health systems

China's model to combat the COVID-19 epidemic: a public health emergency governance approach

Comparative analysis of state-level policy responses in global health governance: A scoping review using COVID-19 as a case

Characterizing the Patterns of China's Policies Against COVID-19: A Bibliometric Study.

Public governance mechanism in the prevention and control of the COVID-19: information, decision-making and execution

The System and Core Mechanisms of Governing Major Pandemic Crisis-a Brief Discussion

Interactive Governance Between and Within Governmental Levels and Functions: A Social Network Analysis of China's Case Against COVID-19.

A Comparative Analysis of Government Responses to COVID-19 in the United States, China, and South Korea: Lessons from the Early Stage of the Pandemic

Challenges and Approaches of the Global Governance of Public Health Under COVID-19

Collaborative Neighborhood Governance and Its Effectiveness in Community Mitigation to COVID-19 Pandemic: from the Perspective of Community Workers in Six Chinese Cities

System dynamics analysis of COVID-19 prevention and control strategies

From Bureaucratic Coordination to a Data-Driven Model: Transformation and Capacity Building of Community-Based Prevention and Control of Public Health Events

Coordinated Management of COVID-19 Response: Lessons From Whole-of-Society and Whole-of-Health Strategies in Wuhan, China

Global pandemic governance: A multilevel concept for managing pandemic crises worldwide