Abstract:We study whether a seller’s gender impacts the bargained-for price in a product market, specifically baseball cards, as well whether any discrimination that might be present is taste-based or statistically-based. We accomplish this by isolating the seller’s gender using an online transaction on eBay where the buyer is exposed to the seller’s gender by only the seller’s hand and name. We test for differential treatment in two environments: a field experiment, in which we actually sell cards on eBay, and a laboratory experiment, in which we conduct surveys via Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk). We find that there is consistent differential treatment of female sellers across both environments. However, this treatment runs in the opposite direction of the discrimination found in most studies of gender. We find that women sell baseball cards for a higher price and greater profit on eBay compared to men. This finding was replicated in the MTurk study. The MTurk study suggested that the reason for a higher price appears to be at least partially based on statistical discrimination, with respondents believing that female sellers were more likely to handle the card carefully and promptly mail it after purchase and less likely to present problems in completing the transaction. Part of the discrimination may also be taste–based. In the eBay experiment, women obtained higher prices and profits even for cards that had been professionally graded, where the quality of the card should not have been in doubt. And MTurk respondents were also more likely to want to meet the female sellers in person and believed they were attractive.

Individual Investors’ Trading Behavior and Gender Difference in Tolerance of Sex Crimes: Evidence from a Natural Experiment

Board Gender Diversity and Cost of Equity: Evidence from Mandatory Female Board Representation

Gender Differences in Stock Market Participation: Evidence From Chinese Households

Gender and Herding

Are All Individual Investors Created Equal? Evidence from Individual Investor Trading Around Securities Litigation Events

Do Investors Trade too Much? Evidence From China's Stock Markets

Sex Discrimination and Female Top Managers: Evidence from China

Executive Gender and Prospect-Value Bias: Evidence from Insider Trading

Boys will be Boys : Gender , Overconfidence , and Common Stock Investment

When Harry Fired Sally: The Double Standard in Punishing Misconduct

Revealed Stock Preferences of Individual Investors: Evidence from Chinese Equity Markets

The Impact of CFO Gender on Corporate Fraud: Evidence from China

Gender Discrimination in Hiring: Evidence from 19,130 Resumes in China

Gender Discrimination in Online Markets

Small Negative Earnings Surprises and Transient Institutions' Trading Behavior

Female CEOs and earnings management: examining risk aversion versus social identity theories

The Gambling Preference and Stock Price: Evidence from China's Stock Market

Trauma and Investment Horizon: Evidence from a Representative China Equity Investor Behavior Survey

Private Information behind Insider Trades: Evidence from Cross Section and Time Series

Gender In-Group Bias: Evidence from Judicial Decisions

Gender Discrimination, Ability and Trust:Based on a Trust Game with Selection