The advantage of cooperation for moderate switching between group exclusion and group reward in the spatial public goods game
Nanrong He,Ke Wu,Qiang Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2023.113668
2023-06-29
Chaos, Solitons and Fractals
Abstract:Group exclusion and group reward are prevalent in institutional management, which are often used to maintain public cooperation and common resources. However, it remains theoretically unclear how the combination of both mechanisms affects social cooperation. Here we propose a conditional switching between group exclusion and group reward based on an assessment threshold in the spatial public goods game. This mechanism implies that once the frequency of cooperators falls below the assessment threshold, all members in the group are excluded, otherwise, they are all rewarded equally. Using Monte Carlo numerical analysis, we find that a moderate switching between group exclusion and group reward (MSER) can quickly establish high level of cooperation even in harsh social dilemmas, while smaller or excessively large assessment thresholds can weaken the cooperative advantage. Furthermore, we reveal that the MSER mechanism has significant advantages over the pure group exclusion and the pure group reward in terms of the evolution of cooperation and the propagation of mechanism. Moreover, the pure group reward clearly outperforms the pure group exclusion in sustaining cooperation only when the synergy factor is relatively small and the reward intensity is high, while the pure group exclusion significantly performs better than the pure group reward only when the synergy factor is relatively large and the reward intensity is small.
mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,physics, mathematical, multidisciplinary