The Pure Legitimacy of Litigation Proceedings

DUAN Hou-sheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-4355.2023.02.06

2023-01-01

Abstract:In essence, “legitimacy” refers to being “in conformity with the essence of the specific object”, and the litigation proceedings are also a kind of two-level communicative order of the legal system. Therefore, the pure legitimacy of litigation proceedings reflects the rationality included in the twolevel communicative order of the legal system. There are four elements to construct the pure legitimacy of litigation proceedings, including the comprehensibility of the speech act, the truthfulness of the statement,the sincerity of the expression, and the legality of the speech acts, among which the legality of the speech acts refers to conformity with the law, except the procedural law. All the rules of litigation proceedings institution aim to promote the realization of the four elements of pure legitimacy. By using these four elements, we could undertake the task of assessing the legitimacy of the institution and practice of litigation proceedings. Whether it is the litigation proceedings themselves or the institution and practice surrounding it, what can promote the pure legitimacy of litigation proceedings is legitimate while what impairs it is illegitimate.