Intercalation Pseudocapacitive Behavior Powers Aqueous Batteries
Dongliang Chao,Hong Jin Fan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chempr.2019.05.020
IF: 23.5
2019-01-01
Chem
Abstract:Pseudocapacitive behavior can enhance kinetics of metal-ion intercalation in most layered materials. In this issue of Chem, Dong et al. report that a unique guest-host chemical interaction offers a new type of intercalation pseudocapacitance that delivers ultra-fast and durable NH4+ storage in an aqueous electrolyte. Pseudocapacitive behavior can enhance kinetics of metal-ion intercalation in most layered materials. In this issue of Chem, Dong et al. report that a unique guest-host chemical interaction offers a new type of intercalation pseudocapacitance that delivers ultra-fast and durable NH4+ storage in an aqueous electrolyte. Rechargeable batteries are an important part of clean and sustainable energy. Despite the reported success in achieving high-energy-density (about 300 Wh kg−1) lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), safety remains a ubiquitous issue that has impeded the application of LIBs in certain areas. In addition, the scarcity (20 ppm) and increasing cost of Li also pose challenges for its large-scale application. The ever-growing demand for electrical energy storage has provoked the global pursuit of alternative batteries that are safer and cheaper than LIBs. Aqueous batteries are a good choice and have attracted tremendous research interests. Over the past four decades, the majority of efforts aimed at novel electrochemical energy storage have conformed to the use of metal ions to shuttle charges. New opportunities are emerging in other metal-ion charge carriers (such as Na+, K+, Zn2+, Mg2+, Ca2+, and Al3+) and non-metal cations (such as proton, hydronium, and ammonium). The attractiveness of rechargeable non-metal-ion batteries resides in the employment of sustainable and unlimited charge carriers on Earth. Compared with metal ions (Figure 1A), non-metal cations not only exhibit lighter molar mass (only 18 g mol−1 for NH4+ and 19 g mol−1 for H3O+) but also deliver smaller hydrated ionic size (3.31 Å for NH4+), which could result in fast diffusion in aqueous electrolytes. Compared with proton or hydronium, NH4+ is less corrosive and suffers less hydrogen evolution. To date, pioneering work on NH4+ host materials has been proposed on Prussian blue analogs (PBAs),1Wessells C.D. Peddada S.V. McDowell M.T. Huggins R.A. Cui Y. The effect of insertion species on nanostructured open framework hexacyanoferrate battery electrodes.J. Electrochem. Soc. 2011; 159: A98-A103Crossref Scopus (310) Google Scholar organic polymers,2Wu X. Qi Y. Hong J.J. Li Z. Hernandez A.S. Ji X. Rocking-chair ammonium-ion battery: a highly reversible aqueous energy storage system.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017; 56: 13026-13030Crossref PubMed Scopus (168) Google Scholar and MXenes.3Lukatskaya M.R. Mashtalir O. Ren C.E. Dall’Agnese Y. Rozier P. Taberna P.L. Naguib M. Simon P. Barsoum M.W. Gogotsi Y. Cation intercalation and high volumetric capacitance of two-dimensional titanium carbide.Science. 2013; 341: 1502-1505Crossref PubMed Scopus (2700) Google Scholar Cui and co-workers compared the effect of insertion ions (Li+, Na+, K+, and NH4+) on PBA and found that NH4+ delivered superior reaction potential and comparable cycling performance.1Wessells C.D. Peddada S.V. McDowell M.T. Huggins R.A. Cui Y. The effect of insertion species on nanostructured open framework hexacyanoferrate battery electrodes.J. Electrochem. Soc. 2011; 159: A98-A103Crossref Scopus (310) Google Scholar Wu et al. further reported a “rocking-chair” ammonium-ion battery (AIB), in which an ammonium Prussian white analog served as the NH4+-insertion cathode and 3,4,9,10-perylenetetracarboxylic diimide served as the anode.2Wu X. Qi Y. Hong J.J. Li Z. Hernandez A.S. Ji X. Rocking-chair ammonium-ion battery: a highly reversible aqueous energy storage system.Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017; 56: 13026-13030Crossref PubMed Scopus (168) Google Scholar The as-assembled AIB demonstrated a cell voltage of 1.0 V and an energy density of 43 Wh kg−1. It has already been shown recently that NH4+ storage in Berlin green results in a higher potential than Na+ and K+ ions insertion and nearly zero strain and therefore has a better cycling performance.4Wu X. Xu Y. Jiang H. Wei Z. Hong J.J. Hernandez A.S. Du F. Ji X. NH4+ topotactic insertion in Berlin green: an exceptionally long-cycling cathode in aqueous ammonium-ion batteries.ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 2018; 1: 3077-3083Crossref Scopus (64) Google Scholar Hence, the NH4+ storage topochemistry is seemingly quite different from metal-ion charge carriers. It has yet to be extensively explored but will certainly stimulate new interests in the battery community. Rate capability is a crucial descriptor for high-power batteries, especially when fast-charging or regenerative braking is required, such as in electric vehicles and drones. The introduction of pseudocapacitance has become an effective method and has been demonstrated widely in various electrode materials for Li-ion and Na-ion storage. The pseudocapacitive process renders much faster charge transfer than volume lattice diffusion and thus can help to retain the capacity at high current rates.5Chao D. Zhu C. Yang P. Xia X. Liu J. Wang J. Fan X. Savilov S.V. Lin J. Fan H.J. Shen Z.X. Array of nanosheets render ultrafast and high-capacity Na-ion storage by tunable pseudocapacitance.Nat. Commun. 2016; 7: 12122Crossref PubMed Scopus (1069) Google Scholar Specifically, pseudocapacitance can be introduced by many methods. For example, nanosizing, increasing electrical conductivity, tuning the crystallinity and crystal phases, introducing mesoporosity, and oxygen deficiency are effecive approaches in enhancing the rate performance and thus power output.6Fan H.J. Pseudocapacitor electrodes: regular pores matter.Joule. 2019; 3: 317-319Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (19) Google Scholar, 7Eftekhari A. Mohamedi M. Tailoring pseudocapacitive materials from a mechanistic perspective.Mater Today Energy. 2017; 6: 211-229Crossref Scopus (97) Google Scholar In fundamental electrochemistry, pseudocapacitance can be classified into three main categories: (1) underpotential deposition, which refers to the electrodeposition of metal monolayer(s) on a foreign metal substrate at potentials that can be significantly less negative than that for deposition on the same metal surface as the adsorbate; (2) surface or near-surface redox pseudocapacitance, where the behavior significantly depends on the surface of nanostructured materials; and (3) intercalation pseudocapacitance, in which charge storage occurs not on the surface but rather in the volume of the material that has 1D or 2D channels in the crystal structure. The principal benefit of intercalation pseudocapacitance is the fast charging within short periods of time because the solid-state phase change is restrained and the process is accompanied by little lattice strain. It has frequently been demonstrated that the intercalation pseudocapacitive behavior boosts the high-rate and long-cycling performances for aqueous batteries.3Lukatskaya M.R. Mashtalir O. Ren C.E. Dall’Agnese Y. Rozier P. Taberna P.L. Naguib M. Simon P. Barsoum M.W. Gogotsi Y. Cation intercalation and high volumetric capacitance of two-dimensional titanium carbide.Science. 2013; 341: 1502-1505Crossref PubMed Scopus (2700) Google Scholar For example, Li-ion intercalation pseudocapacitance in tetragonal LiMn2O4 electrode has shown high rate capability and a long cycle life.9Abdollahifar M. Huang S.-S. Lin Y.-H. Sheu H.-S. Lee J.-F. Lu M.-L. Liao Y.-F. Wu N.-L. Tetragonal LiMn2O4 as dual-functional pseudocapacitor-battery electrode in aqueous Li-ion electrolytes.J. Power Sources. 2019; 412: 545-551Crossref Scopus (23) Google Scholar We have recently developed a high-power and durable solid-state Zn-ion battery in which the 2D layered zinc orthovanadate array cathode explicitly exhibits a significant intercalation pseudocapacitive contribution.10Chao D. Zhu C.R. Song M. Liang P. Zhang X. Tiep N.H. Zhao H. Wang J. Wang R. Zhang H. Fan H.J. A high-rate and stable quasi-solid-state zinc-ion battery with novel 2D layered zinc orthovanadate array.Adv. Mater. 2018; 30: e1803181Crossref PubMed Scopus (459) Google Scholar Despite a new concept battery chemistry, NH4+ storage with high rate capability and long-term cyclability has not yet been achieved. In order to achieve prominent intercalation pseudocapacitive behavior in aqueous batteries, it is necessary to design suitable electrode materials that can accommodate nearly strain-free intercalation of ions at a suitable potential that will not cause a water-splitting reaction. There have been few reports on pseudocapacitive-mechanism-enabled high-rate performance in NH4+ storage. On the one hand, there is no reason that such an effect cannot happen to NH4+ intercalation when suitable electrode materials with one or more of the aforementioned effects are selected; on the other hand, it remains largely unknown how the different topotactic intercalation chemistries between NH4+ and metal ions will affect the high-rate performance. In this issue of Chem, Dong et al. report high-rate reversible NH4+ (de)insertion in a bi-layered V2O5 rendered by a unique intercalation pseudocapacitance in aqueous electrolyte.8Dong S. Shin W. Jiang H. Wu X. Li Z. Holoubek J. Stickle W.F. Key B. Liu C. Lu J. et al.Ultra-fast NH4+ storage: strong H bonding between NH4+ and bi-layered V2O5.Chem. 2019; 5: 1537-1551Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (120) Google Scholar They call it chemisorption-involved-intercalation (CI) pseudocapacitance. In their work, an optimized V2O5 electrode had the dominating bi-layered structure and most suitable amount of crystal water. This V2O5 electrode showed rather stable cycling in the nearly neutral (NH4)2SO4 electrolytes with a reversible capacity of ca. 100 mAh g−1 at 1 C (1 C = 100 mA g−1), corresponding to 0.7 NH4+ per V2O5 formula. Impressively, nearly 50% capacity was retained when the rate increased by 500 times, and 80% capacity was retained after 30,000 cycles at 50 C. Ex situ X-ray diffraction measurements futher confirmed that the solid-state reaction without phase change is associated with the reversible (de)insertion of NH4+ ions. Quantitative analysis of the cyclic voltammetry data revealed that about 94% of the whole NH4+ storage capacity (at a scan rate of 5 mV s−1) originated from a non-diffusion-controlled redox process. This value is much higher than that (75%) of the K+ ion storage in the K2SO4 electrolyte. This large portion also corroborates the intercalation pseudocapacitive behavior rather than surface-redox pseudocapacitance given that the specific surface area of the electrode is quite low (37 m2 g−1) and the nanobelts have a long-range-ordered crystal structure. Such kinetic analysis is nowadays very often employed to distinguish the diffusion-controlled capacity contribution and pseudocapacitive contribution in nanostructured electrodes (an example is given in Figure 1B). It is noteworthy that this mathematic treatment alone is insufficient for concluding the nature of electrochemical reactions; one still needs to check other factors, including the quasi-box cyclic voltammetry and linear dV/dQ (differential potential-capacity relationship). Why is this CI pseudocapacitive storage for NH4+ ions so different from K+ ion storage? These two ions have similar radii and magnitudes of interaction with the V2O5 host, but researchers have found by comprehensive characterizations and density-functional theory calculations that NH4+ ions have unique directional hydrogen (H) bonding with the host. The spherical K+ ion (as well as Li+ and Na+) has no preferred orientations, but NH4+ shows a tetrahedral-shaped multipole. During the migration within the bi-layered V2O5, the ammonium molecule can twist and rotate to maintain a subset of coordinated H bonds with adjacent oxygen atoms (oxygen of either crystal water or V2O5 framework). We can understand this process by imagining a monkey swinging between trees (Figure 1C); the ammonium twists to disconnect one of its trailing H bonds and reaches forward to a new O bond ahead. Although unique, this new mechaism may or may not be a universal process to many layered materials. There are pitfalls to these new ammonium-ion aqueous batteries. First is the low energy density, which is estimated to be a maximum of 55 Wh/kg given only the anode mass. This is associated with the low specific capacity of the V2O5 for NH4+ ions compared with Li ions. The second drawback is that the cell has to be assembled and tested inside a nitrogen glove box because the V2O5 electrode will react with water and oxygen in the presence of air, leading to severe capacity fading upon cycling. So the question is, can we design the crystal structure or choose another host material that can host a higher content of NH4+ and is more stable in ambient air? Overall, it is fundamentally exciting to understand the new chemistry of intercalation pseudocapacitance in this particular NH4+-V2O5 system and its positive role in enhancing high-rate ammonium storage. The work by Dong et al. could inspire us to more carefully check the nature of chemical interactions during a nominal pseudocapacitive process. Hopefully there are more choices of suitable layered materials that can deliver not only ultra-fast aqueous ammonium-ion storage but also high energy density. Financial support from Singapore Ministry of Education Academic Tier 1 grant 2018-T1-001-228 is appreciated. Ultra-fast NH4+ Storage: Strong H Bonding between NH4+ and Bi-layered V2O5Dong et al.ChemApril 11, 2019In BriefDuring the operation of an NH4+-ion battery electrode of a bi-layered V2O5, the charge carrier of NH4+ migrates through the electrode’s lattice in a fashion akin to monkey-bar walking, very different from spherical metal ions. Computation studies reveal that there is a charge transfer from the VO layers to the NH4+ ions via a robust H bonding, where such H bonding has been revealed by characterization. Interestingly, the results point to a correlation between the H bonding and some rarely seen strong pseudocapacitance. Full-Text PDF Open Archive