Abstract:Accurate estimation of the resistances to water vapor movement is a major difficulty in evaluating evaporation from soil. By including the temperature of a dry soil surface (the temperature of the surface of a dry soil column buried in the field), a method for estimating evaporation from soil is proposed. The necessary input variables for the suggested method are temperature, net radiation, and soil heat flux. There are three advantages of the proposed method over the conventional methods. First, soil surface resistance and aerodynamic resistance are not required. Second, the variables included are fewer. Third, measurement and analysis of the parameters involved are relatively easy. Sensitivity analysis shows that the suggested method is sensitive to temperatures. Test experiments were conducted in a sandy field, where a weighing lysimeter was installed. Evaporation from soil, together with the variables specified above, were measured. For temperatures measured by thermocouples, experimental results showed that the mean absolute error (MAE) for the daily evaporation over 22 days was 0.17 mm day1. The regression between calculated and measured evaporation was highly significant (r2 = 0.89). Moreover, the intercept and slope of the regression equation were not significantly different from zero and unity, respectively, at the 0.05 probability level. Furthermore, by using the temperatures measured by infrared thermometers, the MAE between measured evaporation and estimated evaporation was 0.15 mm day−1. The regression between them was highly significant (r2=0.94) In addition, the intercept and slope of the regression equation were not significantly different from zero and unity, respectively, at the 0.05 probability level. These results show that evaporation calculated using the proposed method is in good agreement with lysimeter measured values. By comparing with the temperature difference method, it was shown that the suggested method estimated soil evaporation more accurately than the temperature difference method. Therefore, it is concluded that the proposed method is not only a simple way for application, but also an accurate way to estimate soil evaporation.

Reply to Comment on "on the Estimation of Potential Evaporation under Wet and Dry Conditions" by Jozsef Szilagyi

Reply to Comment on “potential Evaporation and the Complementary Relationship” by Jozsef Szilagyi

Extending the Integrated Richards Equation Method to New Boundary Conditions: Model Description and Validation

Reply to Comment by J. Szilagyi and R. Crago on “derivation of a Sigmoid Generalized Complementary Function for Evaporation with Physical Constraints”

On the Estimation of Potential Evaporation under Wet and Dry Conditions

Comment on "Comparison of the Efficiencies of the Prognostic Generalized Complementary Functions on Evaporation Estimation" by Wang, L., et al., Published in Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres

Interactive comment on "Does evaporation paradox exist in China?" by Z. T. Cong and D. W. Yang

Reply to Hess-2019-701-sc1

Potential Evaporation and the Complementary Relationship

Interactive comment on “Little change in Palmer Drought Severity Index across global land under warming in climate projections” by Yuting Yang et al

Reappraising the appropriate calculation of a common meteorological quantity: Potential Temperature.

Potential evaporation dynamics over saturated bare soil and an open water surface

Comment on “A Calibration‐Free Formulation of the Complementary Relationship of Evaporation for Continental‐Scale Hydrology” by J. Szilagyi Et Al.

A variational method for estimating surface fluxes with mass conservation constraint

Evapotranspiration Over Heterogeneous Vegetated Surfaces: Models and Applications

An improved methodology to measure evaporation from bare soil based on comparison of surface temperature with a dry soil surface

An Improved Approach for Estimating Pan Evaporation Using a New Aerodynamic Mechanism Model

Testing a Maximum Evaporation Theory over Saturated Land: Implications for Potential Evaporation Estimation

Relationship Between Potential and Actual Evaporation in Yangtze River Basin

Reexamination of evaporation from horizontal surfaces with implications for solar interfacial evaporation experiments

Quantifying the Below-Cloud Evaporation of Raindrops Using Near-Surface Water Vapour Isotopes: Applications in Humid and Arid Climates in East Asia