Comparison study on the curative effects between manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers and open reduction and internal fixation with plate in tibial plateau fracture
WANG Zhan-chao,SHANG Yan-chun,YAN Yong-chang,SUN Yong-qiang,ZHANG Jiang-tao,MENG Qing-yang,YAN Zhan-min
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-6015.2012.06.008
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective:To compare and analyze the clinical curative effects between manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers and open reduction and internal fixation with plate in tibial plateau fracture.Methods:Two hundred and thirty-seven patients with tibial plateau fracture enrolled into the study were randomly divided into 2 groups.One hundred and twenty-six patients were administrated with manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers,while the others were administrated with open reduction and internal fixation with plate.Thirty patients with SchatzkerⅠtibial plateau fracture,41 patients with SchatzkerⅡtibial plateau fracture,71 patients with SchatzkerⅣ tibial plateau fracture and 95 patients with SchatzkerV tibial plateau fracture were enrolled into the study.Such scores as knee pain,walking ability,knee extension,range of motion(ROM),joint stability and total scores of knee joint function were recorded and compared between the 2 groups.Such scores as collapse of articular facet,broaden of condyles,varus-valgus deformity of knee joint and total scores of X-ray for knee joint were recorded and compared between the 2 groups.The curative effects were evaluated according to Rasmussen scoring standards of knee joint function for tibial condyles fracture and Rasmussen scoring standards of anatomyfor tibial condyles fracture reduction.Results:For manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers group:time of removing fish-lip pincer is 1.5-2.5 months with median time of 2 months.Time of removing steel needle is 2.5-4.5 months with median time of 3.5 months.Ten cases with needle passage fluids and local skin redness were found from 7 days to 3 months after operation,while they were healed after dressing change without forming sinus and osteomyelitis.Among the 126 cases,122 cases were followed up,3 cases were lost to follow-up and 1 case was rejected for diabetes.Follow-up time was 1-4 years.Fracture healing time was 3-6 months with median time of 4.8 months.For open reduction and internal fixation with plate group:Twelve cases with local skin infection and necrosis were found,among which 10 cases were healed after dressing change,2 cases with partly steel exposure were healed after dressing change and flap transposition.Among the 111 cases,103 cases were followed up,6 cases were lost to follow-up and 2 cases were rejected for refusing to accept this test.Follow-up time was 1-4 years.Fracture healing time was 3-9 months with median time of 6.9 months.Time of removing internal fixation is 12-21 months with median time of 15.3 months after operation.There was no statistical difference in scores of knee pain,walking ability,knee extension,joint ROM,joint stability and total scores of knee joint function between the 2 groups(t=1.655,P=0.200;t=0.153,P=0.696;t=0.860,P=0.355;t=0.691,P=0.407;t=1.697,P=0.194;t=1.845,P=0.176).There was statistical difference in scores of collapse of articular facet,broaden of condyles,varus-valgus deformity of knee joint and total scores of X-ray for knee joint between the 2 groups,X-ray scores of internal fixation group were higher than those of percutaneous fixation group(t=8.695,P=0.004;t=9.601,P=0.002;t=11.493,P=0.001;t=7.935,P=0.005).There was no statistical difference in knee joint function between the 2 groups(Z=-0.236,P=0.814).Fracture reduction effect of open reduction and internal fixation with plate was better than that of manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers(Z=-3.223,P=0.001).Conclusion:Compared with the method of manipulative reduction and percutaneous fixation with fish-lip pincers,open reduction and internal fixation with plate has the advantage of better fracture reduction effect on patients with SchatzkerⅠ,Ⅱ,ⅣandⅤtibial plateau fractures,while the 2 methods have the similar curative effects on knee joint function.Considering the 2 methods have their own advantages and disadvantages,the performers should select the proper fixation method according to their own operation skill levels and hospital conditions.