Competing Against Former Teammates Predicts Match Outcome: Evidence from the Indian Premier League

Satyam Mukherjee,Yun Huang,Brian Uzzi,Noshir Contractor
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4105994
2022-01-01
Abstract:Research question: The small but growing body of research on the team vs. team competition focuses on predicting the winner based on multilevel factors including the team’s strength and prior relations among team members within a team. Our research demonstrates the significance and power of prior relations among members of the competing teams in predicting the outcome of a contest. Research methods: We use data over a period of 8-seasons of the Indian Premier League, to demonstrate the effects of competing against former teammates on the outcome of a Cricket match. If two teams A and B are competing in a match, and nA players from A are former teammates of players on B and nB players from B are former teammates of players on A, then the larger between nA and nB predicts which team will have a competitive advantage over the other team. We call the magnitude of this difference the “ecosystem” factor in predicting performance. Results and findings: Using regression models, Exponential Random Graph Models, and Multiple Regression Quadratic Assignment Procedure we find that the ecosystem factor significantly improves the team’s odds of winning. Implications: These findings provide novel empirical insights to deepen our understanding of the impacts of team assembly mechanisms on performance. Our findings have implications for franchise owners in the Indian Premier League, specifically during the bidding process. While recruiting a player franchise owners should not rely solely on the player’s ability but also leverage the rivalry between former teammates.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?