Abstract:PurposeFocusing on firm-initiated brand communities, the purpose of this paper is to systematically examine the influence of brand community rejection on consumer evaluations and document the underlying mechanism involved.Design/methodology/approachFour empirical studies were conducted to test the proposed hypotheses. Using a similar 2 × 2 study design, different subject samples and different product categories, Studies 1-3 investigated whether a brand community rejection strategy impacted strong brands differently than weak brands. Furthermore, Study 3 measured reactance as a moderator to explore the underlying process of the impact of a brand community rejection strategy on brand evaluations for different types of brands (i.e. strong vs weak). Study 4 used a 2 × 2 × 2 between-subjects design to examine whether justification would eliminate the negative impact of brand community rejection on subsequent brand evaluations for a weak brand.FindingsAcross the four studies, the findings consistently suggest that rejection from firm-initiated brand communities harms weak brands but not strong brands. In addition, by incorporating psychological reactance as a moderator of this effect, the authors uncover the process underlying the interaction between brand community rejection and brand strength. Furthermore, the paper examines the reasons that justify rejection to find a solution that eliminates the negative impact of brand community rejection on brand evaluations for weak brands.Originality/valueTo the best of the authors’ knowledge, this research provides the first investigation of the effects of a brand community rejection strategy for different brands. The findings could advance the social exclusion literature and shed new light on brand community research.

Product design, social exclusion, and product preference: The mediating role of psychological ownership and the moderating role of product type

Social exclusion and choice: The moderating effect of power state

How Social Interactions Demotivate Customer Participation in Creativity Tasks: From the Perspective of Social Exclusion Theory.

How social exclusion and temporal distance influence product choices: the role of coping strategies

The effect of social exclusion on persuasiveness of feelings versus reasons in advertisements: the moderating role of culture

Consumers’ Preference for User-Designed Versus Designer-Designed Products: The Moderating Role of Power Distance Belief

A Study on Product Materials Mental Imagery Perception of User Experience Design

The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?

Warmth or competence: Brand anthropomorphism, social exclusion, and advertisement effectiveness

To Be or Not to Be Unique? The Effect of Social Exclusion on Consumer Choice

A Product Design Based on Interaction Design and Axiomatic Design Theory

An Exemption for Strong Brands: the Influence of Brand Community Rejection on Brand Evaluation

Effects of social exclusion and implicit theories of personality on nostalgic consumption

The Different Choice In Response To Social Exclusion: The Role Of Relationship Orientation

How Social Exclusion Affects Consumers’ Color Preference

Psychological Compensation Under Demand Threat:Research on the Influence of Social Exclusion on Anthropomorphized Brand Role Preference

The Influence of Social Exclusion and Anthropomorphized Brand Roles on Consumers’ Purchase Intention

When Technology Products Meet Social Needs: Product Pricing and Design

The Influence of Social Exclusion Types on Individuals' Willingness to Word-of-Mouth Recommendation.

Social Exclusion and Conspicuous Consumption: The Moderating Effect of Power State

Can Power Predict Consumers’ Preferences for Aesthetic Products? the Moderating Role of Locus of Control