Abstract:Purpose The study of shame has a long tradition in intra- and inter-personal psychology. This paper aims to investigate whether consumers can experience brand shame after self-relevant consumption incidents. Specifically, this research proposes that consumers follow a complex shame-inducing process in the aftermath of unpleasant experiences involving their favorite brand. The moderating role of relational tie strength between consumers and their favorite brand existing prior to symbolic failures is examined. Design/methodology/approach A scenario-based, online survey (n = 660) among consumers who have recently experienced a self-relevant failure with their favorite brand was conducted. Confirmatory factor analysis ensured the reliability and validity of the measurement model. For testing the conceptual model, data was analyzed by means of a moderated mediation analysis. The proposed model was tested against, among others, common method bias and alternative models. The findings were cross-validated with a scenario-based online experiment (n = 1,616). Findings Results show that brand shame is a key mediator between customer dissatisfaction and brand anger when self-relevant, symbolic failures happen. Moreover, strong consumer-brand identification triggers brand-detrimental effects. It is shown to influence the connection between consumers' inward- (i.e. brand shame) and resulting outward-directed (i.e. brand anger) negative emotions on brands, which lead to consumer vengeance. Originality/value To the best of the authors' knowledge, this research is the first to introduce the concept of situational brand shame to the literature on favorite brands. Furthermore, it shows that consumer-brand identification moderates the direct and indirect (via brand shame) unfavorable effects of failure-induced dissatisfaction on brand anger. This research adds insights to the investigation of the "love-becomes-hate" effect arising after self-relevant failures involving consumers' most preferred brand.

An Exemption for Strong Brands: the Influence of Brand Community Rejection on Brand Evaluation

Avoidance or trash talk: the differential impact of brand identification and brand disidentification on oppositional brand loyalty

Warmth or competence: Brand anthropomorphism, social exclusion, and advertisement effectiveness

Brand Communities and New Product Adoption: The Influence and Limits of Oppositional Loyalty

Brand Communities and New Product Adoption:The Influence and Limits of Oppositional Loyalty

Oppositional loyalty as a brand identity-driven outcome: a conceptual framework and empirical evidence

Strong Brand from Consumers’ Perspective: A Cross-Cultural Study

Brand communities: loyal to the community or the brand?

The Influence of Social Exclusion and Anthropomorphized Brand Roles on Consumers’ Purchase Intention

SOCIAL MEDIA BRAND COMMUNITY AND CONSUMER PURCHASE: A CROSS-BRAND ANALYSIS

I am ashamed of my brand-self! Consumer-brand identification as a moderator of emotional reactions following symbol-laden brand failures

The Social Influence of Brand Community: Evidence from European Car Clubs

Online Brand Community Members′ Psychological Compatibility and Community Performance

Antecedents and Consequences of Brand Community Identification: A Case from Chinese Automobile Clubs

The effect of social exclusion on persuasiveness of feelings versus reasons in advertisements: the moderating role of culture

Psychological Compensation Under Demand Threat:Research on the Influence of Social Exclusion on Anthropomorphized Brand Role Preference

Consumers' Role Performance and Brand Identification: Evidence from a Survey and a Longitudinal Field Experiment

How a Brand's Social Activism Impacts Consumers' Brand Evaluations: The Role of Brand Relationship Norms

Effect of Online Brand Community on Customer Behavior Exploration: Reconciling Mixed Findings via Regulatory Focus Theory

The Impact Process of the Consumers' Participating in New Product Idea Brainstorming on Online Brand Community Members' Self-Brand Connection and Brand Attachment

To What Extent Should Emerging Brands Maintain Distinctiveness in the Global Market? the Effect of Brand Isomorphism Level on Brand Evaluation