Abstract:Purpose Previous research has explored the impact of customer participation in organizational‐sponsored loyalty programs on customer loyalty; however, the findings are mixed. Other research, outside the loyalty program literature, reveals that customers who socially interact with other customers, via participation in brand communities, often exhibit an intense loyalty to the sponsoring brands. Proposes to investigate the following questions: “Can loyalty programs be differentiated based on whether or not members perceive a sense of community?”; and “Does a perception of a sense of community impact member loyalty to sponsoring organizations?” Design/methodology/approach Q‐technique factor analysis is utilized analyzing statements from loyalty program participants. Principal component factor and cluster analyses confirm a two‐tiered classification schema distinguishing loyalty programs based on perceptions of communal benefits. Differences between the two factors are explored. A survey developed from the Q‐sort analysis was then administered to 153 loyalty program participants, providing evidence that consumers are more loyal to communal programs. Findings Loyalty programs can be distinguished based on the sense of community which members perceive. Furthermore, consumers are more loyal to communal programs than to programs that simply use financial incentives. Communal programs elicit stronger emotional connections and participants are significantly less predisposed to competitor switching. Originality/value This study integrates the theory of sense of community into the marketing literature, also offering researchers a nine‐item, unidimensional scale to measure the construct within the context of loyalty programs. Confusion in the literature regarding the efficacy of loyalty programs is diminished by showing a positive relationship between loyalty and a member's perceptions of community.

Brand communities: loyal to the community or the brand?

On the relationship between consumer-brand identification, brand community, and brand loyalty

Building Brand Community

The group matters: examining the effect of group characteristics in online brand communities

An Exemption for Strong Brands: the Influence of Brand Community Rejection on Brand Evaluation

Loyalty programs and a sense of community

The Social Influence of Brand Community: Evidence from European Car Clubs

Brand Community Social Capital, Perceived Value and Brand Loyalty

The role of brand community identification and reward on consumer brand engagement and brand loyalty in virtual brand communities

Social Media Brand Communities and Brand Loyalty

Building Brand Loyalty Through Value Co-Creation Practices in Brand Communities: the Role of Affective Commitment and Psychological Brand Ownership

An Empirical Research on the Forming of Students' Loyalty to University Brand from the Brand Community Point of View

Antecedents and Consequences of Brand Community Identification: A Case from Chinese Automobile Clubs

Does Social Media Brand Community Membership Translate to Real Sales? A Critical Evaluation of Purchase Behavior by Fans and Non-Fans of a Facebook Fan Page.

Engaging consumers via online brand communities to achieve brand love and positive recommendations

The Relationship of Online Brand Community, Value Creation Practices, Brand Trust, and Brand Loyalty

Brand communities and self-concept congruency in the case of a music festival

Effects of online brand communities on millennials' brand loyalty in the fashion industry

Consumer engagement in an online brand community

Can social media-based brand communities build brand relationships? Examining the effect of community engagement on brand love

The Mechanism Model of Brand Community Identification Formation: A Case Study of Xiaomi Company