Abstract:Purpose Brand identities have a dual nature that appeals to the head (rational appeal) and to the heart (emotional appeal) of their consumers. Furthermore, consumers can process information in a predominately analytic or intuitive cognitive style (CS) manner. This study aims to analyze the influence of brand identity-cognitive style (BI-CS) fit on the perceived value of a brand. It also analyzes how different forms of social influence affect the perceived value of the brand. Design/methodology/approach Using a two-step experimental design, Step 1 examines the effect that BI-CS fit has on consumer-based brand equity (CBBE); Step 2 evaluates the effect that the three elements of social influence–compliance, identification and internalization–have on CBBE. Findings Both the BI-CS fit, and the identification and internalization forms of social influence have a significant and positive effect over the perceived value of the brand. A rational brand identity is given a higher perceived brand value by analytic CS consumers than intuitive CS consumers. Conversely, an emotional brand identity is given a higher perceived brand value by intuitive CS consumers than analytic CS consumers. However, whether the brand identity is more emotional or rational is less important than the values and beliefs that the brand communicates to create social influence. Research limitations/implications This study contributes to the branding literature by introducing the CS concept to better understand the influence of emotional and rational brand identities on consumers with either rational or intuitive cognitive thinking styles and reinforce the importance of the brand duality concept. Practical implications The results demonstrate the importance of brand duality and show how firms could present emotional or rational brand identities depending on their consumers’ CS to increase the effectiveness of their messaging to build stronger brand images that increase the perceived value of the brand. These findings could have important implications for market segmentation. Originality/value Brand identities can be emotional or rational, and this creates more or less value depending on the consumers’ CS, but what is more important is that consumers internalize the brand’s message or identify with what the brand represents. Although this has been discussed in prior literature, the original contribution of this paper is tying all these concepts together.

The Interaction of Product Attractiveness and Decision-Making Style on Consumer Purchase Intention: A Cultural Moderation Perspective

The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

Consumer decision-making styles, involvement, and the intention to participate in online group buying

The Effect of Alternative vs. Focal Identity Accessibility on the Intent to Purchase Products: An Exploratory Study Based on Chinese Culture

Sustainable Behaviors And Personality Moderating The Status Goal And Purchase Intention Relationship Of Luxury Brands

Collaboration between East and West: influence of consumer dialectical self on attitude towards co-brand personality traits

The effect of brand identity-cognitive style fit and social influence on consumer-based brand equity

Demystifying Cultural Differences in Country-of-Origin Effects: Exploring the Moderating Roles of Product Type, Consumption Context, and Involvement

The Influence of Culture on the Lure of Choice, Mental Accounting, and Overconfidence

Purchase intention and purchase behavior online: A cross-cultural approach

How Do Face Consciousness and Public Self-Consciousness Affect Consumer Decision-Making?

More Proximal, More Willing to Purchase: The Mechanism for Variability in Consumers' Purchase Intention Toward Sincere vs. Exciting Brands

How Chinese Consumers' Intentions for Purchasing Eco-Labeled Products Are Influenced by Psychological Factors

The impact of interpersonal traits (extraversion and agreeableness) on consumers’ self-brand connection and communal-brand connection with anthropomorphized brands

Examining Factors Affecting Consumers’ Purchase Intentions for Chinese Museum’s Cultural and Creative Products

Conceptualising the influence of the cultural orientation of Latin Americans on consumers’ choice of US brands

The Influence of Perceived Cultural Identity on Consumer Purchase Intention of Ethnic Cultural Products: The Mediating Role of Perceived Value

Buy domestic or foreign brands? The moderating roles of decision focus and product quality

Unconscious Drivers of Consumer Behavior: An Examination of the Effect of Nature-Nurture Interactions on Product Desire

The Impact of Cultural Values on Attitude Formation toward Cultural Products: Mediating Effects of Country Image

Usage, Pleasure, Price, and Feeling: A Study on Shopping Orientation and Consumer Outcome