Abstract:This paper investigates a three-echelon closed-loop supply chain (CLSC) consisting of a manufacturer, a distributor, and a retailer, where the retailer exhibits fairness concerns. Cooperative and non-cooperative game theoretic analyses are employed to characterize interactions among different parties. Analytical results confirm the conventional wisdom: with the retailer's fairness concerns, the channel profits under the decentralized and partial-coalition models underperform that under the centralized model. To find an appropriate profit allocation scheme to coordinate the supply chain system with fairness concerns, we resort to the cooperative game theory. To this end, we first derive the characteristic function form of the cooperative game based on the equilibrium profits under centralized, decentralized and different partial-coalition models. Subsequently, we propose three coordination mechanisms based on the Shapley value, nucleolus solution, and equal satisfaction to allocate surplus profit. The three mechanisms are then evaluated by using numerical experiments. We further examine how the retailer's fairness concerns affect profit allocation under the three mechanisms. The key innovation is to incorporate the retailer's fairness concerns into the coordination of a three-echelon CLSC. Our contributions are twofold: First, cooperative game-theoretic mechanisms are put forward to coordinate the three-echelon CLSC with a fairness-minded retailer. Second, we investigate how the retailer's fairness concerns affect the CLSC members' pricing decision and surplus profit allocation. Our studies confirm that the resulting profit allocation schemes satisfy both individual and collective rationality and fall in the core of the cooperative game, thereby making the grand coalition stable and suggesting viable options to coordinate the CLSC system. Further analyses reveal that different coordination mechanisms benefit the three CLSC members differently. These research findings help CLSC managers to understand what options are available and identify possible pathways for them to foster cooperation and achieve equitable allocation of surplus profit.

Unfair and Risky? Profit Allocation in Closed-Loop Supply Chains by Cooperative Game Approaches

Cooperative Game Approaches to Coordinating a Three-Echelon Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Fairness Concerns

Cooperative Game Analysis of A Supply Chain with One Risk-Neutral Supplier and Two Risk-Averse Retailers

Optimal decisions in a closed-loop supply chain: fairness concerns, corporate social responsibility and information value

A Novel Cooperative Game-Based Method to Coordinate a Sustainable Supply Chain under Psychological Uncertainty in Fairness Concerns

Complex Dynamics in a Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Risk Aversion and Fairness Concerns Under Supply Disruption

A dual-channel secondary closed-loop supply chain considering retail groups and fairness concerns

Interactive Impact of Fairness Concerns and Competition on Supply Chain Coordination

Pricing Models in Supply Chains under Exponential Demand with Absolute Fairness Concerns

Research on the Complex Features about a Dual-Channel Supply Chain with a Fair Caring Retailer

Dynamic Corporate Social Responsibility Adjustment Strategies of a Closed-Loop Supply Chain with Fairness Concerns and Supply Chain Financing

Game theoretic analysis of prices and low-carbon strategy considering dual-fairness concerns and different competitive behaviours

Research on Decision-Making and Coordination of Dual-Channel Closed-Loop Supply Chain Considering Retailer's Fairness Concerns

Profit Allocation on a Four-Echelon Supply Chain in Perspective of Cooperative Games on Augmenting Systems.

Quality and Retail Pricing Decision in a Supply Chain with Fairness Concerns

Cooperative Game Analysis of Coordination Mechanisms under Fairness Concerns of a Green Retailer

Dynamic analysis of a dual-channel closed-loop supply chain with fairness concerns under carbon tax regulation

Pricing and Coordination Decisions in Autonomous Reduction Low-Carbon Supply Chain with Fairness Concerns

Fairness In Performance Of Supply Chain And Contract Design

A dual-channel supply chain model considering supplier’s mental accounting and retailer’s fairness concerns

Green supply chain game model and contract design: risk neutrality vs. risk aversion