Injured Self-Image: Rethinking the Critique of Chinese National Character as an Intellectual Discourse
Guo Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1179/tcr.2007.14.2.266
2007-01-01
The Chinese Historical Review
Abstract:In 1985, the Taiwanese-Chinese writer Bo Yang published his influential book, Choulou de Zhongguoren (The Ugly Chinese) in Taiwan, and the book was soon reprinted in Mainland China in 1986. In this collection of essays and speeches, Bo Yang described the Chinese people as being noisy, dirty, crude, quarrelsome, dishonest, ill-mannered, and unwilling to admit mistakes. Bo Yang's scathing evaluation of the Chinese has been either condemned or welcomed among Chinese readers since its appearance. Lucian W. Pye suggests that Russian intellectuals and revolutionaries had a stronger sense of self-criticism of their national character than their Chinese counterparts, partially due to its Christian legacy. In fact, the critique of a Chinese national character was at least no less pungent than the Russian discourse. In a sense, Bo Yang revived a tradition in the modern Chinese intellectual discourse—self-reflection and criticism of Chinese national character, which emerged in the late 19th century, but was suppressed on both sides of the Taiwan Strait after 1949 due to the populist pretensions of the two opposed governments. This paper examines the arguments made by numerous Chinese intellectuals—reformers, revolutionaries, writers, and scholars—on Chinese national character and evaluates the origin, transition and multi-faceted implications of the polemics on Chinese national character in a historical context of the rising Chinese nationalism and self-definition throughout the traumatic twentieth century. It attempts to demonstrate that the “guominxing pipan” (critique of the national character) as an intellectual discourse was an interplay of arising nationalist consciousness, selected strains of modern European theories, as well as Chinese intellectuals'f desperate and largely emotionalist search for the roots of Chinese weakness.