Beyond Brokerage Position: Deployment of Multiple Brokering Behaviors and Impacts on Performance
Hongzhi Chen,Brian R. Dineen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2019.13144abstract
2019-01-01
Abstract:Brokerage and brokering are ubiquitous and consequential phenomena in organizations. Classic research overly relies on a structural definition of brokerage and holds a homogeneous view of brokerage phenomena. Recent research has proposed a behavioral construal of brokerage phenomena and formulated three forms of brokering behaviors, i.e., collaborative, mediation, and separation brokering. We systematically examine the effects of these brokering behaviors on individual performance. With empirical data from research scientists at an R&D Center, we find that different brokering behaviors distinctly impacted performance. Moreover, we find a positive externality on the receiving side of collaborative brokering. However, we also uncover a “too-much-of-a-good-thing” effect of collaborative brokering on the focal broker’s performance. Inspired by Obstfeld’s insight that “broker repertories consist of different combinations of these behaviors” (Obstfeld, 2017: 42), we complement the current study with a person-centered approach. Using latent profile analysis, we identify four configural profiles of brokers: non-brokers, average brokers, disjoiners, and bridges. The result provides a conceptually useful representation of deployment of multiple brokering behaviors, which yields insights consistent with those from the variable-centered approach. Overall, this paper illuminates the complexity and richness of brokering phenomena.