Abstract:We consider the problem of fairly allocating indivisible public goods. We model the public goods as elements with feasibility constraints on what subsets of elements can be chosen, and assume that agents have additive utilities across elements. Our model generalizes existing frameworks such as fair public decision making and participatory budgeting. We study a groupwise fairness notion called the core, which generalizes well-studied notions of proportionality and Pareto efficiency, and requires that each subset of agents must receive an outcome that is fair relative to its size. In contrast to the case of divisible public goods (where fractional allocations are permitted), the core is not guaranteed to exist when allocating indivisible public goods. Our primary contributions are the notion of an additive approximation to the core (with a tiny multiplicative loss), and polynomial time algorithms that achieve a small additive approximation, where the additive factor is relative to the largest utility of an agent for an element. If the feasibility constraints define a matroid, we show an additive approximation of 2. A similar approach yields a constant additive bound when the feasibility constraints define a matching. For feasibility constraints defining an arbitrary packing polytope with mild restrictions, we show an additive guarantee that is logarithmic in the width of the polytope. Our algorithms are based on the convex program for maximizing the Nash social welfare, but differ significantly from previous work in how it is used. As far as we are aware, our work is the first to approximate the core in indivisible settings.

The Core of School Choice Problems

School Choice with Multiple Priorities

On Stable and Efficient Mechanisms for Priority-Based Allocation Problems

School Choice as a One-Sided Matching Problem: Cardinal Utilities and Optimization

A New Perspective on School Choice with Consent

On the Core of Markets with Co-ownerships and Indivisibilities

A new perspective on Kesten's school choice with consent idea.

Coalition and Core in Resource Allocation and Exchange

Constrained School Choice with Incomplete Information

Fair Allocation of Indivisible Public Goods

Priority-Based Affirmative Action in School Choice

Core-Stability in Assignment Markets with Financially Constrained Buyers

Stable Matching with Contingent Priorities

Weak Stability and Pareto Efficiency in School Choice

Ex-post core, fine core and rational expectations equilibrium allocations

Cores in discrete exchange economies with complex endowments

A Pseudo-Market Approach to Allocation with Priorities

The Core of the Participatory Budgeting Problem

A Cost-Minimizing Algorithm for School Choice

Hierarchical Exchange Rules and the Core in Indivisible Objects Allocation

The size of the core in assignment markets