Quantitative Strategies for Determining the Reliability of Biostratigraphic Data

Norman Macleod,Gerta Keller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s2475262200002574

1996-01-01

The Paleontological Society Special Publications

Abstract:An abstract is not available for this content so a preview has been provided. As you have access to this content, a full PDF is available via the ‘Save PDF’ action button.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Techniques for quantitative stratigraphic correlation: a review and annotated bibliography

J. C. Tipper

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0016756800013224

1988-09-01

Geological Magazine

Abstract:Abstract The development of techniques for quantitative stratigraphic correlation has tended to outstrip their acceptance by practising stratigraphers. To make these techniques more readily accessible and to encourage their use, this paper presents a brief, general review of the problem of quantitative stratigraphic correlation and then shows how, using a natural framework for stratigraphic correlation, the stratigraphic time-series, there can be seen an orderly pattern among them. The annotated bibliography, of almost 400 articles, includes a majority of those references concerned with quantitative stratigraphic correlation, in whatever sense: the scheme of annotation provides a straightforward, albeit subjective indication of the general thrust of each article.

geosciences, multidisciplinary
Applications of quantitative biostratigraphy in chronostratigraphy and time scale construction

József Pálfy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.29041/strat.04.2.13

2007-01-01

Stratigraphy

Abstract:Quantitative biostratigraphy finds useful applications in chronostratigraphy and time scale calibration. Fixing the Global Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP) is made more objective if correlation potential of alternative boundary levels is compared using the Unitary Association (UA) method. The base of the Ladinian (Middle Triassic) GSSP is a case in which not the regionally most easily correlatable ammonoid datum was selected. Radio-isotopic dates are often obtained outside the province where the primary standard biozonation is established, introducing a correlation uncertainty into time scale calibration. In the Early Jurassic, an uncertainty of approximately one standard ammonoid substage is demonstrated using the UA method, if using a North American U-Pb date requires correlation with the northwest European zonation. The resolution of the time scale was significantly improved for the Ordovician and Silurian by employing constrained optimization to construct a global sequence of graptolite bioevents. Interpolation between the available U-Pb dates is possible by scaling using the assumption of near-constant sedimentation rate in pelagic facies. Future uses of quantitative biostratigraphy may include exploitation of large paleontologic databases (e.g. the Paleobiology Database) and contribution to the generation of dynamic, interactive geologic time scales.

geology,paleontology
A New Approach to Quantifying Stratigraphical Resolution: Application to Global Stratotypes

Michael J. Melchin,H. David Sheets,Charles E. Mitchell,Junxuan Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12193

2017-01-01

Lethaia

Abstract:Horizon annealing (HA) provides a method to order all horizons in a chronostratigraphic data set, including marker beds and isotopic excursions, as well as horizons that lack exact local markers (such as taxon first appearances) and are, thus, constrained only by local stratigraphical order. Global stratotype section and point (GSSP) levels placed within an HA composite succession can be precisely correlated with levels in all other sections in the composite that span the same interval. We present two approaches to the quantitative assessment of the uncertainty or error in the placement of horizons within the composite section: a permutation method (jackknife analysis) and a sensitivity analysis (the relaxed fit curve). From jackknife analysis, we calculate a standard deviation (sigma) of the variation in horizon placements and estimate the 95% confidence interval of the variation in horizon placement within the composite. We also directly assess the relative stability of event positions using the results of the jackknife. These approaches provide an objective method for assessing the relative strengths of GSSP candidates, in which we prefer those sections and horizons that are the most precisely controlled in the HA composite. Integration of biostratigraphical, chemostratigraphical and lithostratigraphical marker horizons into the HA process markedly improves levels of constraint within the composite compared to biostratigraphical data alone. In a temporally scaled composite, the 95% confidence intervals on horizon placements could be used to estimate temporal resolution. In our study, we estimate that the average temporal resolution is approximately 319 kyr, which approaches the range of that needed to test hypotheses of orbitally driven cyclicity.
Descriptive and quantitative analysis of fracture systems in a carbonate rock mass complex

J Gallas,T Backers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/833/1/012060

2021-08-01

IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science

Abstract:Abstract The study area is located in the Franconian Alb in Southern Germany and is an Upper Jurassic, karstified and fractured, regularly bedded carbonate rock mass with thin marl interlayers. Structurally, these deposits are heterogeneous and a classification into structural types is striven for in this study. The structural classification is based on discontinuity and fault characteristics gained from field work. The study area is considered an analogue for Germanys most productive deep geothermal reservoir horizon in the South German Molasse Basin. The aim of the field study is to describe and quantitatively analyse the different structural types, and to optimize the scanline method for a specific geological setting to gain comprehensive information with regard to fracture permeability and rock mass behaviour. The structural types are described in terms of discontinuity orientation and density, rock strength, and fault characteristics. To optimize the scanline method for the field study additional discontinuity attributes were added. One of these accessory attributes, the existence of discontinuity lags, will be discussed. It occurs when vertical and sub-vertical fractures cross sedimentary layers and continue with a small horizontal displacement in the next sedimentary layer. The results of this study are used to improve derived fracture networks with respect to thermo-hydro-mechanical models in the geothermal sector. Following article discusses the first results of the above-mentioned field study.
Reliability analysis of basal-heave in a braced excavation in a 2-D random field

Zhe Luo,Sez Atamturktur,Yuanqiang Cai,C. Hsein Juang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compgeo.2011.08.005

IF: 5.218

2012-01-01

Computers and Geotechnics

Abstract:A simplified approach to consider the effect of spatial variability in a two-dimensional (2-D) random field for reliability analysis of basal-heave in a braced excavation in clay is presented. In contrast to the random field modeling (RFM) approach, which necessitates use of Monte Carlo simulation (MCS), the proposed approach employs the equivalent variance technique to consider the effect of spatial variability so that the analysis for probability of basal-heave failure can be performed using well-established first-order reliability method (FORM). Case study shows that this simplified approach yields results that are nearly identical to those obtained from the MCS-based RFM approach. The proposed approach is shown to be effective and efficient for probabilistic analysis of basal-heave in a braced excavation in a 2-D random field.
Quantifying Stratigraphic Uncertainties by Stochastic Simulation Techniques Based on Markov Random Field

Zhao Li,Xiangrong Wang,Hui Wang,Robert Y. Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enggeo.2015.12.017

IF: 6.902

2015-01-01

Engineering Geology

Abstract:Stratigraphic (or lithological) uncertainty refers to the uncertainty of boundaries between different soil layers and lithological units, which has received increasing attention in geotechnical engineering. In this paper, an effective stochastic geological modeling framework is proposed based on Markov random field theory, which is conditional on site investigation data, such as observations of soil types from ground surface, borehole logs, and strata orientation from geophysical tests. The proposed modeling method is capable of accounting for the inherent heterogeneous and anisotropic characteristics of geological structure. In this method, two modeling approaches are introduced to simulate subsurface geological structures to accommodate different confidence levels on geological structure type (i.e., layered vs. others). The sensitivity analysis for two modeling approaches is conducted to reveal the influence of mesh density and the model parameter on the simulation results. Illustrative examples using borehole data are presented to elucidate the ability to quantify the geological structure uncertainty. Furthermore, the applicability of two modeling approaches and the behavior of the proposed model under different model parameters are discussed in detail. Finally, Bayesian inferential framework is introduced to allow for the estimation of the posterior distribution of model parameter, when additional or subsequent borehole information becomes available. Practical guidance of using the proposed stochastic geological modeling technique for engineering practice is given.
A computational framework to systematize uncertainty analysis in the sediment fingerprinting approach using least square methods

Lidiane Buligon,Tiago Martinuzzi Buriol,Jean Paolo Gomes Minella,Olivier Evrard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40314-024-02948-4

2024-10-19

Computational and Applied Mathematics

Abstract:Simulating sediment transfer processes in catchments has contributed significantly to solving environmental problems due to its importance in the silting of rivers and reservoirs and for controlling the pollution of water bodies. Among the methods used to improve data collection and modelling, the "sediment fingerprinting approach" uses tracers reflecting the composition of eroded soils and sediments in multivariate statistical analyses and mathematical models for optimizing equation systems. Based on generalized least squares (GLS) method and Mahalanobis distance, this study sought to present a computational framework to solve over-determined systems applied to sediment tracing, systematize the uncertainty analysis and sample number optimization. Hence, this approach takes into account the influence of collinearity among the chemical variables that compose the tracer set to be evaluated by the presence of the variance-covariance matrix. A dataset from the Arvorezinha experimental catchment in southern Brazil was used to validate the modeling, and our findings confirmed the assumption of increased uncertainty as the number of target samples decreases in the sources or eroded sediment samples. Sharing the code files with the PySASF (Python package for Source Apportionment with Sediment Fingerprinting) contributes to improving the technique as it allows other researchers to systematically improve the definition of the number of samples required based on the uncertainty analysis.

mathematics, applied
Reliability analysis with scarce information: Comparing alternative approaches in a geotechnical engineering context

michael beer,yi zhang,s t quek,k k phoon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strusafe.2012.10.003

IF: 5.712

2013-01-01

Structural Safety

Abstract:In this paper the problem of dealing with scarce information in a reliability analysis is investigated in a geotechnical engineering context. Common probabilistic methods are compared with interval analysis as an alternative non-probabilistic approach. The potential of imprecise probabilities is discussed as an option for combining probabilistic and non-probabilistic information. The selected methods are examined in view of (i) an appropriate modeling of the information actually available in practical cases, (ii) the transfer of the uncertainty to the computational results, and (iii) the interpretation of the results. Key issue of this investigation is the meaning of the results as the basis to derive engineering decisions if only scarce information is available. This involves particular attention to low-probability-but-high-consequence events, which are often essential for risk assessment. A retaining wall structure is adopted for this study, and the failure mechanisms are considered as known in a deterministic form. This describes the input-to-output transformation of the available information in all cases. Representative available information about the parameters of the retaining wall problem is taken from literature, and typical practical specifications for the parameters are considered.
Uncertainty and Reliability Analysis of Open Pit Rock Slopes: A Critical Review of Methods of Analysis

Musah Abdulai,Mostafa Sharifzadeh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10706-018-0680-y

2018-08-29

Geotechnical and Geological Engineering

Abstract:The stability analyses of slope excavations in rock mass require reliable geomechanical input parameters such as rock mass strength, friction angle and cohesion of sliding surface. These parameters are naturally uncertain and their exact values cannot be known, therefore, their variability must be properly accounted for in the stability analyses. Deterministic approaches such as the limit equilibrium methods, numerical methods and kinematic analysis methods do not account for the variability in any of the input parameter. This paper therefore provides a review of uncertainty and uncertainty analysis methods, problems and developments in geotechnical modelling of rock slope stability. The review is motivated by the availability of qualitative and number of methods for uncertainty analysis. The paper examines the various definitions and description of uncertainty and the different vocabularies that are used, and also summarises and categorises the different sources of uncertainty as well as integrating uncertainty for rock slope assessment problems. The paper discussed a simple survey of probability-based reliability methods that have been used for rock slope stability analysis in the past 3 decades.
How Many Grains Are Needed for Quantifying Catchment Erosion from Tracer Thermochronology?

Andrea Madella,Christoph Glotzbach,Todd A. Ehlers

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/gchron-4-177-2022

2022-01-01

Geochronology

Abstract:Abstract. Detrital tracer thermochronology exploits the relationship between bedrock thermochronometric age-elevation profiles and a distribution of detrital grain-ages collected from river, glacial, or other sediment to study spatial changes in the distribution of catchment erosion. If ages increase linearly with elevation, spatially uniform erosion is expected to yield a detrital age distribution that mirrors the catchment's hypsometric curve. Alternatively, a mismatch between detrital and hypsometric distributions may indicate non-uniform erosion within a catchment. For studies seeking to identify the pattern of erosion, measured grain-age populations rarely exceed 100 grains due largely to the time and costs related to individual measurements. With sample sizes of this order, discerning between two detrital age distributions produced by different catchment erosion scenarios can be difficult at a high statistical confidence level. However, there is no established method to quantify the sample-size-dependent uncertainty inherent to detrital tracer thermochronology, and practitioners are often left wondering how many grains is enough?. Here, we investigate how sample size affects the uncertainty of detrital age distributions and how such uncertainty affects the ability to uniquely infer the erosional pattern of the upstream area. We do this using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistic as metric of dissimilarity among distributions, based on which the statistical confidence of detecting an erosional pattern is determined through Monte Carlo sampling. The techniques are implemented in a new tool (ESD_thermotrace) to consistently report confidence levels as a function of sample size and application-specific variables. The proposed tool is made available as a new open-source Python-based script along with test data. Testing between different hypothesized erosion scenarios with this tool provides thermochronologists with the minimum sample size (i.e. number of bedrock and detrital grain-ages) required to answer their specific scientific question, at their desired level of statistical confidence. Furthermore, in cases of unavoidably small sample size (e.g., due to poor grain quality or low sample volume), we provide a means to calculate the confidence level of interpretations made from the data.
Quantified active learning Kriging model for structural reliability analysis

Ioannis Prentzas,Michalis Fragiadakis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.probengmech.2024.103699

IF: 2.954

2024-10-26

Probabilistic Engineering Mechanics

Abstract:A quantified active learning Kriging-based (qAK) methodology for structural reliability analysis is presented. The proposed approach is based on an updated probability density function (PDF), which is dominant in the vicinity of the limit-state surface. This PDF is created using weights based on an improved learning function called the most probable misclassification function. This function is used as a metric for efficiently updating the Kriging model, as it symmetrically quantifies the uncertainty of candidate points in terms of the model's accuracy. The proposed approach accurately approximates the points that lie on the limit-state surface. Moreover, a probabilistic-based stopping criterion is proposed. The new support points are selected using the weighted K -means algorithm and the sample from the updated PDF. Thus, the method does not require solving an optimization problem or using a sampling algorithm. The proposed qAK methods are more reliable and robust than previous implementations of the Kriging method for structural reliability assessment. The proposed approach is presented within the framework of standard reliability methods, i.e., the Monte Carlo and the Subset Simulation methods. The efficiency of the proposed qAK methods is demonstrated with the aid of six case studies.

engineering, mechanical,mechanics,statistics & probability
Data inaccuracy quantification and uncertainty propagation for bibliometric indicators

Paul Donner

2024-10-22

Abstract:This study introduces an approach to estimate the uncertainty in bibliometric indicator values that is caused by data errors. This approach utilizes Bayesian regression models, estimated from empirical data samples, which are used to predict error-free data. Through direct Monte Carlo simulation - drawing many replicates of predicted data from the estimated regression models for the same input data - probability distributions for indicator values can be obtained, which provide the information on their uncertainty due to data errors. It is demonstrated how uncertainty in base quantities, such as the number of publications of a unit of certain document types and the number of citations of a publication, can be propagated along a measurement model into final indicator values. Synthetic examples are used to illustrate the method and real bibliometric research evaluation data is used to show its application in practice. Though in this contribution we just use two out of a larger number of known bibliometric error categories and therefore can account for only some part of the total uncertainty due to inaccuracies, the latter example reveals that average values of citation impact scores of publications of research groups need to be used very cautiously as they often have large margins of error resulting from data inaccuracies.

Digital Libraries
Quantitative study of bioclastic grains in carbonate rocks:Theoretical analysis and application of point-counting method

Wen Junjun,Liu Jianbo

2009-01-01

Journal of Palaeogeography

Abstract:The abundance of bioclastic grains in carbonate rocks is of great value in researches of fossil diversity and reconstruction of paleoecological environment. It can be easily valued with point-counting method,which is more suitable for carbonate rock than the other two quantitative approaches-visual estimation and image analysis. However,few studies have been attempted to determine how many points should be counted to yield adequate and precise results,which made the point-counting procedure time-consuming. By comparative analysis of the comparison charts for visual percentage estimation and microphotographs of the Ordovician carbonate rocks,this study focuses on how these attributes influence the precision of point-counting method,and discusses a moderate number of points which facilitates the method. As a result,a number of 500 points or so is appropriately enough for precise measure of the abundance of the referred component in most of carbonate thin sections with an error of ±2.5%,and should be adjusted with abundance,grain size,sorting as well as biodiversity of bioclasts in thin sections.
Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits

Suzanne M. Leal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/318209

2001-02-01

The American Journal of Human Genetics

Abstract:Unknown

genetics & heredity
Blending measurements and numerical models: a novel methodological approach for land subsidence prediction with uncertainty quantification

Laura Gazzola,Massimiliano Ferronato,Matteo Frigo,Pietro Teatini,Claudia Zoccarato,Anna Antonia Irene Corradi,Maria Carolina Dacome,Ernesto Della Rossa,Michela De Simoni,Stefano Mantica

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/piahs-382-457-2020

2020-04-22

Proceedings of the International Association of Hydrological Sciences

Abstract:Abstract. The use of numerical models for land subsidence prediction above producing hydrocarbon reservoirs has become a common and well-established practice since the early '90s. Usually, uncertainties in the deep rock behavior, which can affect the forecast capability of the models, have been taken into account by running multiple simulations with different constitutive laws and mechanical properties. Then, the most uncertain parameters were calibrated to reproduce available subsidence measurements. The objective of this work is to propose a novel methodological approach for land subsidence prediction and uncertainty quantification by integrating the available monitoring information in numerical models using ad hoc Data Assimilation techniques. The proposed approach allows to: (i) train the model with the available data and improve its accuracy as new information comes in, (ii) quantify the prediction uncertainty by providing confidence intervals and probability measures instead of deterministic outcomes, and (iii) identify the most appropriate rock constitutive model and geomechanical parameters. The methodology is tested in synthetic models of production from hydrocarbon reservoirs. The numerical experiments show that the proposed approach is a promising way to improve the effectiveness and reliability of land subsidence models.
Improved absolute abundance estimates from spatial count data with simulation and microfossil case studies

Chris Mays,Marcos Amores,Anthony Mays

2024-06-16

Abstract:Many fundamental parameters of biological systems -- eg. productivity, population sizes and biomass -- are most effectively expressed in absolute terms. In contrast to proportional data (eg. percentages), absolute values provide standardised metrics on the functioning of biological entities (eg. organisism, species, ecosystems). These are particularly valuable when comparing assemblages across time and space. Since it is almost always impractical to count entire populations, estimates of population abundances require a sampling method that is both accurate and precise. Such absolute abundance estimates typically entail more "sampling effort" (data collection time) than proportional data. Here we refined a method of absolute abundance estimates -- the "exotic marker technique" -- by producing a variant that is more efficient without losing accuracy. This new method, the "field-of-view subsampling method" (FOVS method) is based on area subsampling, from which large samples can be quickly extrapolated. Two case studies of the exotic marker technique were employed: 1, computer simulations; and 2, an observational "real world" data set of terrestrial organic microfossils from the Permian- and Triassic-aged rock strata of southeastern Australia, spiked with marker grains of known quantity and variance. We compared the FOVS method against the traditional "linear method" method using three metrics: 1, concentration (specimens/gram of sediment); 2, precision and 3, data collection effort. In almost all cases, the FOVS method delivers higher precision than the linear method, with equivalent effort, and our computer simulations suggest that the FOVS method more accurately estimates the true error for large target-to-marker ratios. Since we predict that these conditions are typically common, we recommend the new FOVS method in almost every "real world" case.

Quantitative Methods
Designing the Scientific Cradle for Quantitative Biologists.

Qi Ouyang,Luhua Lai,Chao Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/sb3000386

IF: 5.249

2012-01-01

ACS Synthetic Biology

Abstract:ADVERTISEMENT RETURN TO ISSUEPREVViewpointNEXTDesigning the Scientific Cradle for Quantitative BiologistsQi Ouyang*, Luhua Lai, and Chao TangView Author Information Center for Quantitative Biology, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China*E-mail: [email protected]Cite this: ACS Synth. Biol. 2012, 1, 7, 254–255Publication Date (Web):July 20, 2012Publication History Received24 April 2012Published online20 July 2012Published inissue 20 July 2012https://doi.org/10.1021/sb3000386Copyright © 2012 American Chemical SocietyRIGHTS & PERMISSIONSArticle Views807Altmetric-Citations2LEARN ABOUT THESE METRICSArticle Views are the COUNTER-compliant sum of full text article downloads since November 2008 (both PDF and HTML) across all institutions and individuals. These metrics are regularly updated to reflect usage leading up to the last few days.Citations are the number of other articles citing this article, calculated by Crossref and updated daily. Find more information about Crossref citation counts.The Altmetric Attention Score is a quantitative measure of the attention that a research article has received online. Clicking on the donut icon will load a page at altmetric.com with additional details about the score and the social media presence for the given article. Find more information on the Altmetric Attention Score and how the score is calculated. Share Add toView InAdd Full Text with ReferenceAdd Description ExportRISCitationCitation and abstractCitation and referencesMore Options Share onFacebookTwitterWechatLinked InReddit PDF (5 MB) Get e-AlertsSUBJECTS:Biology,Chemical engineering and industrial chemistry,Mathematical methods,Students,Undergraduates Get e-Alerts
Is the past recoverable from the data? Pseudoproxy modelling of uncertainties in palaeoecological data

Quinn Asena,George LW Perry,Janet M Wilmshurst

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/09596836241247304

IF: 3.09

2024-05-07

Holocene

Abstract:The Holocene, Ahead of Print. There is growing concern about the response of contemporary ecosystems to increasing and novel anthropogenic pressures and environmental conditions. Palaeoecology is crucial to understanding how ecosystems have responded to past environmental changes and can inform management of contemporary ecosystems and contribute to forecasts of ecosystem responses to change. However, palaeoecological data are subject to uncertainties that arise from environmental processes, field and laboratory methods, and data processing, and that affects inferences drawn from them. Understanding how different sources of uncertainty affect the analyses of proxy records remains limited, and records are often interpreted solely qualitatively. We present a virtual ecology approach for assessing how uncertainties inherent in empirical proxy data influence statistical analyses and the inferences drawn from them. In the virtual ecology approach, both the data and the observational process are recreated in simulation to assess sampling and analytical methods. We demonstrate results from a new model for simulating core-type samples of pseudoproxies comparable to empirical proxy data but not subject to the same sources of proxy and chronological uncertainties. These 'error-free' pseudoproxies generated under known driving conditions have uncertainties (e.g. core mixing, sub-sampling, and proxy quantification) systematically introduced to them to assess how individual and combined sources of uncertainty influence analytical methods. Results indicate that inferences drawn from statistical analysis, such as the stability of a system, or the rate of ecological turnover, can change substantially between the 'error-free' pseudoproxies, and degraded and sub-sampled data. We show how our approach can advance understanding of uncertainties in palaeoecological data and how it can help shape research questions by quantifying of their influence on proxy data.

geosciences, multidisciplinary,geography, physical
Digital reconstruction of reservoir sandstones to predict hydraulic and mechanical rock properties

Maria Wetzel,Thomas Kempka,Michael Kühn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/egusphere-egu21-1512

2021-03-03

Abstract:Quantifying trends in hydraulic and mechanical properties of reservoir sandstones has a wide practical importance for many applications related to geological subsurface utilization. In that regard, predicting macroscopic rock properties requires detailed information on their microstructure [1]. In order to fundamentally understand the pore-scale processes governing the rock behaviour, digital rock physics represents a powerful and flexible approach to investigate essential rock property relations [2]. This was shown, e.g., for hydraulic effects of anhydrite cement in the Bentheim sandstone in relation to an unsuccessful drilling campaign at the geothermal well Allerm&#246;he, Germany [3]. Rock weakening due to decreasing calcite mineral content was also demonstrated by application of numerical simulations [4].&#160;In the present study, a process-based method is used for reconstructing the full 3D microstructure of three typical reservoir reference rocks: the Fontainebleau, Berea and Bentheim sandstones. For that purpose, grains are initially deposited under the influence of gravity and afterwards diagenetically consolidated. The resulting evolution in porosity, permeability and rock stiffness is examined and compared to the respective micro-CT scans of the sandstones. The presented approach enables to efficiently generate synthetic sandstone samples over a broad range of porosities, comprising the microstructural complexity of natural rocks and considering any desired size, sorting and shape of grains. In view of a virtual laboratory, these synthetic samples can be further altered to examine the impact of mineral dissolution and/or precipitation as well as fracturing on various petrophysical correlations, what is of particular relevance for a sustainable exploration and utilisation of the geological subsurface.[1] Wetzel M., Kempka T., K&#252;hn M. (2017): Predicting macroscopic elastic rock properties requires detailed information on microstructure. Energy Procedia, 125, 561-570. DOI: 10.1016/j.egypro.2017.08.195&#160; [2] Wetzel M., Kempka T., K&#252;hn M. (2020): Hydraulic and mechanical impacts of pore space alterations within a sandstone quantified by a flow velocity-dependent precipitation approach. Materials, 13, 4, 3100. DOI: 10.3390/ma13143100 [3] Wetzel M., Kempka T., K&#252;hn M. (2020): Digital rock physics approach to simulate hydraulic effects of anhydrite cement in Bentheim sandstone. Advances in Geosciences, 54, 33-39. DOI: 10.5194/adgeo-54-33-2020&#160; [4] Wetzel M., Kempka T., K&#252;hn M. (2018): Quantifying rock weakening due to decreasing calcite mineral content by numerical simulations. Materials, 11, 542. DOI: 10.3390/ma11040542&#160;
The replication crisis and its relevance to Earth Science studies: Case studies and recommendations

Stephen J. Puetz,Kent C. Condie,Kurt Sundell,Nick M.W. Roberts,Christopher J. Spencer,Slah Boulila,Qiuming Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsf.2024.101821

IF: 8.9

2024-03-10

Geoscience Frontiers

Abstract:Highlights • Testing for replicability requires independent data. • A replicable global time-series requires a high globality index. • Proxy data is an alternative when direct data is unavailable. • Geological samples are seldom selected randomly, which requires adjustments. • Filtering a database for the highest quality records could enhance replicability. Numerous scientific fields are facing a replication crisis, where the results of a study often cannot be replicated when a new study uses independent data. This issue has been particularly emphasized in psychology, health, and medicine, as incorrect results in these fields could have serious consequences, where lives might be at stake. While other fields have also highlighted significant replication problems, the Earth Sciences seem to be an exception. The paucity of Earth Science research aimed at understanding the replication crisis prompted this study. Specifically, this work aims to fill that gap by seeking to replicate geological results involving various types of time-series. We identify and discuss 11 key variables for replicating U-Pb age distributions: independent data, global sampling, proxy data, data quality, disproportionate non-random sampling, stratigraphic bias, potential filtering bias, accuracy and precision, correlating time-series segments, testing assumptions and divergent analytical methods, and analytical transparency. Even while this work primarily focuses on U-Pb age distributions, most of these factors (or variations of them) also apply to other geoscience disciplines. Thus, some of the discussions involve time-series consisting of ε Hf, δ 18 O-zircon, 14 C, 10 Be, marine δ 13 C, and marine δ 18 O. We then provide specific recommendations for minimizing adverse effects related to these factors, and in the process enhancing prospects for replicating geological results. Graphical abstract Download : Download high-res image (378KB) Download : Download full-size image

geosciences, multidisciplinary

Quantitative Strategies for Determining the Reliability of Biostratigraphic Data

Techniques for quantitative stratigraphic correlation: a review and annotated bibliography

Applications of quantitative biostratigraphy in chronostratigraphy and time scale construction

A New Approach to Quantifying Stratigraphical Resolution: Application to Global Stratotypes

Descriptive and quantitative analysis of fracture systems in a carbonate rock mass complex

Reliability analysis of basal-heave in a braced excavation in a 2-D random field

Quantifying Stratigraphic Uncertainties by Stochastic Simulation Techniques Based on Markov Random Field

A computational framework to systematize uncertainty analysis in the sediment fingerprinting approach using least square methods

Reliability analysis with scarce information: Comparing alternative approaches in a geotechnical engineering context

Uncertainty and Reliability Analysis of Open Pit Rock Slopes: A Critical Review of Methods of Analysis

How Many Grains Are Needed for Quantifying Catchment Erosion from Tracer Thermochronology?

Quantified active learning Kriging model for structural reliability analysis

Data inaccuracy quantification and uncertainty propagation for bibliometric indicators

Quantitative study of bioclastic grains in carbonate rocks:Theoretical analysis and application of point-counting method

Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits

Blending measurements and numerical models: a novel methodological approach for land subsidence prediction with uncertainty quantification

Improved absolute abundance estimates from spatial count data with simulation and microfossil case studies

Designing the Scientific Cradle for Quantitative Biologists.

Is the past recoverable from the data? Pseudoproxy modelling of uncertainties in palaeoecological data

Digital reconstruction of reservoir sandstones to predict hydraulic and mechanical rock properties

The replication crisis and its relevance to Earth Science studies: Case studies and recommendations