Abstract:Many key industries (e.g., biomedical, pharmaceuticals, telecommunications, and information technologies) are characterized by cumulative innovations, where the introduction of a new product or service often requires many complementary technologies. When these technologies are protected by intellectual property rights owned by many firms, patent thickets exist, which researchers have argued may hinder the development of cumulative innovations. Specifically, patent thickets may lead to excessive royalty burdens for potential licensees, which is called “royalty stacking,” and if such costs are passed on to consumers, prices of products based on cumulative technologies will be driven up, dubbed as “double marginalization.” The literature, however, does not address these issues under different forms of licensing contracts. This article develops a game‐theoretic model where a downstream firm seeks to license N patents that read on its product from upstream firms. It discusses a variety of licensing forms widely used in practice and attempts to discover whether royalty stacking and double marginalization occur under these forms of licenses. It also studies the impact of bargaining power between parties. It is found that when patent ownership becomes more fragmented, neither royalty stacking nor double marginalization occurs under profit‐based royalty, fixed fee, and hybrid licenses. Such problems occur only under pure quantity‐based or pure revenue‐based royalty licenses when the downstream firm's bargaining power is low. It is also shown that no matter how fragmented the ownership structure of patent is, hybrid licenses consisting of a fixed fee and a quantity‐ or revenue‐based royalty rate lead to the same market outcomes as a fully integrated firm that owns all the patents and the downstream market. This article has interesting implications for both research and practice. First, the results show that even under the same patent ownership structure, different forms of licenses lead to quite different market outcomes. Therefore, it is suggested that firms and policy makers pay more attention to contractual forms of licenses when trying to minimize the negative impact of patent thickets. Second, the extant literature has largely assumed that quantity‐based royalties are used, where double marginalization is the most severe. In practice, revenue‐based royalties are most common, under which double marginalization is much milder. Third, the results show that patent pools can be most effective in mitigating royalty stacking and double marginalization when quantity‐based or revenue‐based royalties are the sole or primary payment form, especially when downstream firms have low bargaining power.

Managing a Supply-Chain Based Two-Sided Market

Decision Structure and Performance of Networked Technology Supply Chains

Decision Structure and Outcomes in Technology Supply Chains

Technology licensing contract design considering royalty transparency and demand information asymmetry with downstream co-opetition

Channel Selection and Contracting in the Presence of a Retail Platform

Manufacturer encroachment in a platform supply chain: An analysis of synergy effect, dysergy effect, and mutual exclusivity effect

Simulation modeling and analysis on the network effects of multi-value chain based on the third-party manufacturing platform

Strategic introduction of marketplace platform and its impacts on supply chain

The Expansion and Stability of Two-Sided Platform Ecological Networks: an Analysis Based on the Leverage Theory of Tying

Paid or Free? The Manufacturer's Revenue Strategy in Response to the Developer's Entry in Technology Platform Market

Two-sided dynamic pricing and value-added service investment strategies of competitive platforms considering indirect network effects

Manufacturer’s selling mode choice in a platform-oriented dual channel supply chain

Supplier Encroachment, Information Sharing, and Channel Structure in Online Retail Platforms

Manufacturer Channel Encroachment and Evolution in E-Platform Supply Chain: An Agent-Based Model

An agent-based model to study the market dynamics of perpetual and subscription licensing

Pricing Strategy of Two-Sided Markets under Vertical Integration Structure

Licensing Strategies in the Presence of Patent Thickets

Information sharing strategy in supply chains: The role of C2M

Platforms with Restrictive Licensing

Coopetitive Supply Chain Relationship Model: Application to the Smartphone Manufacturing Network

Strategic analysis of manufacturer encroachment in dual-channel supply chains with platform service