Abstract:Low-pressure two-phase flow instabilities can potentially challenge start-up transients of water-cooled nuclear reactors. Predicting oscillations caused by flow instability is therefore paramount to reactor safety. While many thermal hydraulics system codes are developed as general-purpose tools, their performance is not guaranteed outside their optimized application ranges. The current study therefore performs validations of two thermal hydraulics system analysis codes, the Adaptive SYStem Thermal-hydraulics Version 3 (ASYST VER3) and Reactor Excursion and Leak Analysis Program MOD3.3 (RELAP5/MOD3.3), in reproducing oscillatory two-phase flow induced by low-pressure flashing instability. Benchmark conditions are selected from a novel dataset resolving void fraction with radial resolution and quantifying periodic behavior with ensemble averaging. Focusing on the prediction of transient two-phase phenomena rather than the determination of stability, validations are conducted by simulating a single channel under prescribed periodic boundary conditions. ASYST exhibits a systematic underprediction of void fraction in an adiabatic chimney downstream of a heated section. The prominent causal discrepancy is identified as a lost travelling void wave due to overpredicted condensation. RELAP5 noticeably overpredicts subcooled boiling and underpredicts flashing, which is consistent with existing validations against steady-state separate-effect tests under low pressure. This degraded code performance also suggests that in low-pressure transients prone to flashing instability, the confidence in RELAP5 derived from existing validations against integral-effect tests shall be carefully limited to validated capabilities in integral systems. In general, the current study fills the previous gap of knowledge about the performance of ASYST and RELAP5 in predicting detailed transient two-phase phenomena in low-pressure flashing-induced oscillations. The identified code defects reveal future directions for code improvements eventually towards reliable application of ASYST and RELAP5 under low pressure beyond their original calibration.

ICONE23-1046 MODELLING OF LOW-PRESSURE SUBCOOLED FLOW BOILING USING ATHLET CODE

Evaluation and Correction of Low-Pressure Subcooled Flow Boiling Model for Athlet Code

Investigation of Bubble Interaction in a Temporal and Spatial Heat Flux Partitioning Model for Subcooled Flow Boiling

Feasibility Analysis of the Modified ATHLET Code for Supercritical Water Cooled Systems

Investigation on the Subcooled Boiling in Vertical Pipe with Uncertainties from Boundary Conditions by Using FLUENT

Modification and Application of the System Analysis Code ATHLET to Trans-Critical Simulations

Numerical Investigation of Flow Boiling Characteristics in Narrow Rectangular Channels Using Two-Fluid Eulerian Cfd Model Covering a Wide Range of Pressures

ATHLET Code and Its Application in Low Temperature Heating Reactor

System code validation in periodic two-phase flow from low-pressure oscillations

Modeling of Low-Pressure Subcooled Boiling Flow of Water Via the Homogeneous MUSIG Approach

Theoretical model for subcooled upward flow boiling heat transfer and critical heat flux for an inclined downward heated surface

PREDICTION OF SUBCOOLED BOILING WITH UNCERTAINTIES FROM BOUNDARY CONDITIONS AND INTERACTION MODELS

A Theoretical and Experimental Study on Subcooled Flow Boiling under Passive IVR-ERVC Conditions

Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Sub-Cooled Boiling, Condensation, and Void Flashing in Nuclear Heating Reactor Test Loop

Numerical Simulation of Subcooled Boiling Water in Vertical Concentric Annulus under Low Pressure

Critical Heat Flux Prediction Model for Low Quality Flow Boiling

A Unifying Bubble-Layer-Based Theoretical Model for Flow Boiling and Application to a Rod Bundle

Numerical Analysis on Subcooled Boiling in PWR Coolant Channel Based on a Modified Multi-Scale Interface Model

Analysis of Subcooled Boiling in PWR Rod Bundle Channel

Development of a Sub-Channel Analysis Code Based on the Two-Fluid Model and Its Preliminary Assessment

Investigation And Modeling Of The In-Tube Heat Transfer Of Fluids At Supercritical Pressure During Heating