Insiders Trading on Unknown Unknowns

Burkhard C. Schipper,Hang Zhou

2021-01-01

Abstract:We study a CARA-normal asset market with a continuum of traders under asymmetric awareness of components affecting the mean or the variance of the fundamental value of the asset. While the prior literature focuses on asymmetric information, we focus on asymmetric awareness. A trader is unaware of a component of the fundamental value (e.g., a line item of the balance sheet or profit & loss of the stock’s firm) if she does not conceive of it and hence does not even know that she does not know it. Traders interact in a uniform price double auction with asymmetric awareness and private information. We derive the linear symmetric Bayes-Nash equilibrium best understood as a prediction in the medium-run because every realization is consistent with every trader’s awareness but in the very long run traders may statically learn that they are biased. We study market depth, price precision, price volatility, and ex ante trading volume including some comparative statics w.r.t. the distribution of traders’ awareness. In a version of the model with common signals, we study the incentives of aware traders to raise the awareness of other traders. We completely characterize the nonempty set of signals and pre-disclosure market prices for which aware traders raise the awareness of unaware traders. Disclosure of awareness occurs when pre-disclosure market clearing prices would be “too low” or “too high” given the signal.