On the Sophistication of Financial Investors and the Information Revealed by Prices

Andres Carvajal,Hang Zhou
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/jdg.2024024
2024-01-01
Journal of Dynamics and Games
Abstract:Does increasing the traders' understanding of the functioning of financial markets lead to rational expectations equilibrium? We provide an answer by studying a simple exchange economy with complete markets and asymmetric information. Each trader is either a fundamentalist, who knows the probability distributions of random shocks, or a speculator trying to infer those probability distributions from asset prices. Starting with the na{\"i}ve beliefs that asset prices transmit no information, the speculators learn the mapping from asset prices to probabilities through adaptive observation. Our results are that: (1) convergence to rational expectations requires that speculators have less market impact than fundamentalists; (2) convergence, when it takes place, occurs in an oscillating manner; and (3) asset prices can be more volatile than at rational expectations equilibrium when speculators display low sophistication. We characterize the necessary conditions on convergence to rational expectations equilibrium for some specific utility functions (CRRA and CARA) and discuss the evolution of wealth, through simulations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?