The Effects Of R & D Cooperation With Uncertainty And Spillover

Lei Yang,Xuejun Xu

2006-01-01

Abstract:In this paper, an attempt is made to generalize and unify the previous results. We provide a thorough generalization of previous results on the comparative performance of non-cooperative and cooperative R&D. The purpose of this paper is to formalize the concept of an optimal R&D cartel and provide a characterization of its properties. In this literature, our focus is on a performance evaluation of various forms of cooperative R&D relative to non-cooperative R&D for firms competing in a product market. We show how the nature of the spillovers affects firms' R&D behavior and the incentive to cooperate, and also study the incentive to cooperate in many contexts, including cooperation in markets with complement as well as substitute products and cooperation among firms in the same and in different industries.We adopt a more general functional form than did previous authors, and consider a dynamic model, and allow for the possibility that the firms are unequal. We show that when spillovers are offsetting competition tends to be preferred to cooperation, but with incremental spillovers. cooperation tends to be the more desirable. Cost sharing usually leads to increased investment and profits compared with a fully competitive R&D market. However, it is not the most profitable form of cooperation. In most cases firms prefer a RJV to cooperation with cost sharing, and a RJV is always preferred to information sharing (IS) agreements.