Abstract:Purpose Both the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) and the popular press have routinely criticized firms for the complexity of their financial disclosures. This study aims to investigate how financial analysts respond to the tone complexity of firm disclosures. Design/methodology/approach Using approximately 20,000 earnings conference call transcripts of S&P 1,500 firms between 2005 and 2015, the authors first calculate the abnormal negative tone, the measure of tone complexity; then use such tone measure in econometric models to examine analyst forecast behavior. The authors also test the robustness of the results under different model specifications, tone word lists and alternative tone measure calculations. Findings Consistent with the notion that analysts respond to the information demand from investors and incur more costs and effort to analyze firm disclosure when the tone is more complex, the authors find that higher tone complexity is positively and significantly associated with more analyst following, longer report duration, more forecast revisions, larger forecast error and larger forecast dispersion. In addition, the authors find that tone complexity has a long-term impact on analyst following but has a limited long-term impact on analyst report duration, analyst revision, forecast error and dispersion. Originality/value This study complements existing literature by highlighting the information role of financial analysts and by providing evidence that analysts incorporate the management tone disclosed during conference calls to adjust their forecasting behaviors. The results can be used by policymakers as evidence and support for further improving firm communication from a new dimension of disclosure tone.

Is Textual Tone Informative or Inflated for Firm's Future Value? Evidence from Chinese Listed Firms

Can the MD&A Tone of Listed Firms' Annual Reports Predict Their Future Performance? Empirical Evidence Based on Machine Learning Text Analysis

Beyond Cheap Talk: Management's Informative Tone in Corporate Disclosures

Textual Tone in Corporate Financial Disclosures: a Survey of the Literature

Does the Management Tone Information Convey the Level of Firm Innovation? : Evidence from Earnings Communication Conferences of GEM Listed Companies

Does management tone matter in information disclosure? Evidence from IPO online roadshows in the SSE STAR market

Management's tone in MD&A disclosure and investment efficiency: Evidence from China

The annual report tone and return Comovement—Evidence from China's stock market

Annual report tone and divergence of opinion: evidence from textual analysis

Do Fund Managers' Tones Predict Future Performance? Evidence from China

Does the Textual Tone of Analyst Reports Have Valuable Information? Korean Evidence

Cost of Equity Capital and Annual Report Tone Manipulation

Can Management Tone Predict IPO Performance? – Evidence from Mandatory Online Roadshows in China

Stock Exchange Comment Letters and MD&A Tone Management

The Impact of Tones of Executive Communication on Firm Risk-Taking: Evidence from Performance Volatility and Acquisition Spending

Do Investors Listen for the Meanings Behind Executives’Words? an Empirical Analysis Based on Management Tones

Textual Analysis and Future Performance: Evidence From Item 1A and Item 7

Tone emphasis and insider trading

Tone Complexity and Analyst Forecast Behaviors: Evidence from Earnings Conference Calls

A Blessing and a Burden! the U-Shaped Relationship Between Managerial Tone and Corporate Risk Taking

Earnings management and CSR report tone: Evidence from China