Abstract:This study explores the impact of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance, Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) framework adoption, and ESG reporting assurance on the tone of ESG disclosures among Chinese listed firms. The research analyzes a dataset of 5985 observations from Chinese listed companies. It employs empirical methods to examine the relationships between ESG performance, GRI framework adoption, ESG reporting assurance, and ESG disclosure tone. The study finds a positive link between high ESG performance and a more optimistic ESG reporting tone, aligning with signalling theory. Conversely, adopting the GRI framework and ESG reporting assurance limits the use of positive tones, consistent with impression management principles. This underscores the importance of governance mechanisms in influencing responsible reporting and mitigating corporate hypocrisy. Additional tests affirm these findings, addressing potential endogeneity concerns. This study contributes to the existing literature on ESG reporting by providing empirical evidence on the influence of ESG performance and managerial tools on reporting tones. It establishes a positive link between ESG performance and ESG reporting tone and highlights the governance function of ESG reporting assurance and the GRI framework in curtailing managerial tendencies to manipulate tone. The paper bridges a research gap by responding to calls for more research into what drives the tone of ESG information. It cements the relevance of signalling theory in ESG and affirms that the deployment of GRI and ESG reporting assurance can serve as tools to inhibit impression management.

The annual report tone and return Comovement—Evidence from China's stock market

Cost of Equity Capital and Annual Report Tone Manipulation

News Tone and Stock Return in Chinese Market

Annual report tone and divergence of opinion: evidence from textual analysis

Does management tone matter in information disclosure? Evidence from IPO online roadshows in the SSE STAR market

Can the MD&A Tone of Listed Firms' Annual Reports Predict Their Future Performance? Empirical Evidence Based on Machine Learning Text Analysis

Annual Report Opacity and Stock Returns: Evidence from China

Stock Exchange Comment Letters and MD&A Tone Management

Annual report text's positive tone and corporate green innovation: Evidence from China

Annual report text’s positive tone and corporate green innovation: Evidence from China

Textual Tone in Corporate Financial Disclosures: a Survey of the Literature

Comovement between China and U.S.'s Stock Markets

Combining Big Data Analysis to Study the Relationship between the Tone of CSR Reports and Information Asymmetry

Does the Management Tone Information Convey the Level of Firm Innovation? : Evidence from Earnings Communication Conferences of GEM Listed Companies

Communication and Comovement: Evidence from Online Stock Forums

Information disclosure transparency and shareholder wealth: Based on textual analysis

Tone emphasis and insider trading

Can Management Tone Predict IPO Performance? – Evidence from Mandatory Online Roadshows in China

End-word tones of stock names and stock price anomalies: Empirical evidence from China's IPO markets

The impact of ESG performance, reporting framework, and reporting assurance on the tone of ESG disclosures: Evidence from Chinese listed firms

Is the tone of the government-controlled media valuable for capital market? Evidence from China's new energy industry