Evaluation of Contaminant Transport Modeling Software for Groundwater Environmental Impact Assessment
Xiaomao ZHANG,Jun ZHOU,Xiaofeng XIONG,Shuo QI,Xiaoqing SHI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13198/j.issn.1001-6929.2018.08.08
2019-01-01
Abstract:Currently,a series of groundwater contaminant transport modeling software have been developed both at home and abroad,but the functions of different programs are different,which makes them difficult for the users to select. In order to meet the meticulous requirements for environmental impact prediction in the 'Technical Guidelines of Environmental Impact Assessment,Groundwater Environment'(HJ 610-2016),we evaluate the applicability of commonly used contaminant transport modeling software to saturated zones and vadose zones respectively. Firstly,for commonly used saturated zone contaminant transport modeling software BIOSCREEN,AT123D and MT3D,we evaluate their applicability by comparing their outputs of 4 sets of hydrodynamic conditions based on a synthetic saturated example. Secondly,For the vadose zone contaminant transport modeling software,which is not documented in the guidelines,we use FEMWATER as an example to discuss the importance of the retardation effect of vadose zones on the environmental impact assessment of groundwater. The results show that: (1) Because BIOSCREEN ignores the molecular diffusion of solute,the predicted concentration of pollutants at 10 m downstream of the pollution source is 1. 8 times higher than that predicted by AT123D and MT3D with Pe of 0. 25× 10-3,which may lead to overestimating the risk of contamination. (2) Compared with the scenario where the pollution source is directly placed above the phreatic surface,the pollution source intensity is reduced by 24％ when the pollutant passes through the 11 m thick vadose zone and then reaches the phreatic surface,and the time is delayed 390 d when the concentration of the pollutant reaches 0. 1 mg/L at 85 m downstream of the pollution source. (3) When the groundwater flow rate is slow and the molecular diffusion is superior to the convection effect,it is recommended to carry out numerical simulation with MT3D or to use AT123D for analytical prediction; when convection is dominant and hydrogeological conditions are close to the analytical solution hypothesis,it is recommended to use BIOSCREEN to roughly estimate the risk of pollution. The use of the vadose zone transport modeling software helps to reasonably predict the transport and transformation behavior of pollutants in the groundwater,thereby more accurately estimating the pollution source intensity and determining the risk of groundwater contamination.