Abstract:The annotation scheme of dependency treebanks might have an impact on the results of linguistic analysis, thus leading to different interpretations of linguistic phenomena. This study compares the results of two widely used dependency measures, i.e., dependency direction and dependency distance, based on 18 parallel Universal Dependencies (UD) annotated treebanks and 18 corresponding Surface-Syntactic Universal Dependencies (SUD) annotated treebanks. The results show that (1) Based on the semantic UD and syntactic SUD, dependency relations between function words and content words share the opposite dependency directions but similar dependency distances; (2) Annotation scheme has a significant impact on dependency direction, though the effect size is small. We find that the proportions of head-final dependencies based on the syntactic SUD can better group language families than those based on semantic UD; (3) Annotation scheme also affects dependency distance significantly, though its effect size is small. Mean dependency distances (MDDs) based on UD are always higher than those based on SUD. However, theMDDs based on both annotation schemes are within a certain threshold, which shows that the linguistic universal of dependency distance minimization is independent of annotation schemes.

How Do Universal Dependencies Distinguish Language Groups?

Chinese Syntactic and Typological Properties Based on Dependency Syntactic Treebanks

Dependency direction as a means of word-order typology: A method based on dependency treebanks

Classifying Syntactic Categories in the Chinese Dependency Network.

The Status of Function Words in Dependency Grammar: A Critique of Universal Dependencies (UD)

Quantitative Typological Analysis of Romance Languages

A Chinese Dependency Syntax for Treebanking

Typometrics: From Implicational to Quantitative Universals in Word Order Typology

Which Annotation Scheme is More Expedient to Measure Syntactic Difficulty and Cognitive Demand?

Syntactic Features of the Noun A dependency tree-based quantitative Study

A Quantitative Analysis of English Variants Based on Dependency Treebanks

Semantic Roles or Syntactic Functions: the Effects of Annotation Scheme on the Results of Dependency Measures

Interlanguage: a Perspective of Quantitative Linguistic Typology

Using A Chinese Treebank to Measure Dependency Distance

Dependency Distance: A New Perspective on Syntactic Patterns in Natural Languages.

Language clusters based on linguistic complex networks

DDM at Work: Reply to comments on “Dependency distance: A new perspective on syntactic patterns in natural languages”

The Complexity of Chinese Syntactic Dependency Networks

Probability Distribution of Dependencies Based on A Chinese Dependency Treebank

How Do Local Syntactic Structures Influence Global Properties in Language Networks?

Dependency Distances and Their Frequencies in Indo-European Language