Perceived Unfairness within Marketing Channel Relationships:Psychological Contracts and Zone-of-unfairness-tolerance
Zhai Senjing,Huang Pei,Gao Weihe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2008.06.014
2008-01-01
Abstract:Unfairness within marketing channels causes great harm to channel relationships.Distribution channels in the Chinese market in particular abound with suppliers' complaints about being unfairly treated by certain giant retailers(for example over the charging of entry and promotion fees,extending payment periods etc.),which result in severe conflicts and even the dissolution of some relation-ships.However,most of the literature in recent decades has been confined to investigating the effect of fairness on relationships,while little research observes the relationship through the lens of unfair-ness.To a great extent,this accounts for the lack of suggestions on how to monitor relationships and maintain good relationships.This paper explores perceived unfairness by vulnerable parties.First of all,a psychological contract is introduced to marketing channel relation-ships.It is proposed that an explicit contract assures an exchange will happen.A relational contract emerging from mutual interaction fos-ters shared values between channel members,while a psychological contract refers to the obligation of the other" in the eye of the one it-self",which reveals how the focal party makes decisions.Next,three key characteristics of a psychological contract are identified:it is informal,subjective,and originates in reciprocal promissory obliga-tions.The correlation between psychological contracts and perceived unfairness is verified.In addition,the zone-of-unfairness-tolerance is defined as the span within which the focal party may be indifferent to some unfair treatment and their behavior or behavioral intention does not change.The zone is then characterized by economic value and relational value.The shift of its boundaries is discussed depending on the focal party's different unfairness perception and its role orienta-tion.The new framework will help discover why a channel member decides to take actions such as cooperating,complaining,committing acts which result in conflict,or even terminating the relationship.This study not only advances our understanding about unfairness by inves-tigating its effect based on the zone-of-tolerance,but also broadens our view of relationships and thus helps maintain a healthy marketing channel relationship.