Abstract:Purpose Scholars have conducted extensive research regarding contractual governance in marketing channels. Operationalizing contractual governance intensity as contract specificity, researchers focused on the impact of contract specificity, while little effort has been paid to the impact of contract enforcement. As a distinct construct of contractual governance mechanism, contract enforcement largely determines the integrity of contracts and the effectiveness of their coordination effects. Dividing contractual governance into contract specificity and contract enforcement, this paper examines the direct and interactive effects of contract specificity and contract enforcement on channel opportunism and conflict. It tries to answer: (1) How do contract specificity and distributor contract enforcement affect supplier opportunism and channel conflict respectively? (2) What are the interactive effect of specificity and enforcement when they are considered simultaneously? Methodology/Approach The paper proposed a research model by taking contract specificity, distributor contract enforcement and their interaction as the antecedents, and supplier opportunism and channel conflict between distributor and supplier as the consequences. To test the model, with the help of a large domestic household appliance supplier in China, we collected data from the side of distributors, and analyzed the data from 607 valid responses with structural equation model (SEM). Findings Both contract specificity and distributor contract enforcement would respectively inhibit supplier opportunism, and supplier opportunism in turn would be positively associated with channel conflict. On the other hand, distributor contract enforcement would increase, while contract specificity would have an insignificant impact on, channel conflict. In addition, interaction between distributor contract enforcement and contract specificity would reduce both supplier opportunism and channel conflict. Originality/Value/Contribution This paper tries to make three contributions. First, it investigated the impact of contractual governance in marketing channels in more depth by dividing contractual governance into two dimensions, namely contractual specificity and contract enforcement, enriching the literature of contractual governance in marketing channels. Second, it empirically tested the impacts of contract enforcement on supplier opportunism and channel conflict between distributor and supplier, to which previous studies have paid little attention. Third, it for the first time considered the interactive effects of contract specificity and contract enforcement on channel opportunism and channel conflict. As a result, it provides a new line of explanation for previous inconsistencies in the effect of contract specificity on channel opportunism as well as channel enforcement on channel opportunism. Practical implications Firms are encouraged to draft specific contracts with their channel partners despite the time and effort required by both parties based on the findings of this research and previous studies. However, contracts should be carefully enforced. According to the findings of this study, if imposed highly strict, contract enforcement may intensify channel conflict between partners.

Perceived Unfairness within Marketing Channel Relationships:Psychological Contracts and Zone-of-unfairness-tolerance

Curbing opportunism in marketing channels: The roles of influence strategy and perceived fairness

Perceptual Difference of Dependence and Its Impact on Conflict in Marketing Channels in China: an Empirical Study with Two-Sided Data

The Impact of Relationship Marketing Orientation on Marketing Channel Behaviors

Channel Coordination under Retailer's (sub)conscious Preferences of Loss Aversion and Fairness

Channel Relationship,Exercises of Power and Opportunistic Behavior in Marketing Channel

Impact of Contract Specificity and Enforcement on Channel Opportunism and Conflict

Supply chain coordination considering fairness concerns

The Impact of Consumer Fairness Seeking on Distribution Channel Selection: Direct Selling vs. Agent Selling

Research on Decision-Making and Coordination of Dual-Channel Closed-Loop Supply Chain Considering Retailer's Fairness Concerns

Cooperative Advertising in a Distribution Channel with Fairness Concerns.

The Effect of Destructive Behaviors on Channel Cooperation and Performance:The Contingent Role of Governance Mechanism

The Opportunism Behavior Research of China Channels

Effect Of Fairness On Channel Choice Of The Mobile Phone Supply Chain

Fairness’s effect on the pricing decisions in a supply chain

Fairness’ s Influences to the Retailer’s Ordering Decision

The Impact of Relationship Marketing Orientation and Interfirm Personal Guanxi on Firms' Relational governance in Marketing Channels

How to Break the Vicious Circle of Channel Opportunism:- A contingency framework of contract and relational governance

Psychological Contract Breach and Compensation of Online Customer Service Failure

Online-Offline Uniform Pricing Strategy of Multi-Channel Retailer Based on Fairness Preferences

When does Relational Governance Inhibit Opportunism in Marketing Channels? The Moderating Effect of Interorganizational Relationship Quality