Abstract:In a series of papers Holmstrom, Milgrom and Roberts have argued that incentives for agents tend to be complementary under certain conditions. A growing body of empirical literature also appears to support this notion. Data constraints, however, have limited the studies to some particular industries or to a selective few aspects in agency contracts. This paper examines the complementarity and substitutability of CEO incentives of more than 300 Chinese state-owned enterprises from a panel data set. The data contain rich information about CEO pay sensitivity; whether the CEO posted performance bond; managerial discretion in production, in employee wage discretion, share of output to sell to the market (versus being required to deliver to the state at lower price); and contract duration. In explaining the interaction of incentives, we extend the framework of Holmstrom and Milgrom (1994) to accommodate the case of multiple signals for the manager's effort for each task. We classify the various incentive instruments into three tasks of CEOs: to pursue current financial performance, to invest for future financial performance, and to work on other activities that yield private benefits. The model then suggests that these three incentive indices should be complementary, and the individual incentives within an incentive index should be substitutes. Our empirical examination confirms these predictions. A side product of getting the conditional correlations is to be able to examine the determinants of the three incentive indices. We find that the determination of CEO incentives for current performance is consistent with the risk-incentive tradeoff hypothesis. The determination of managerial discretion is consistent with the incomplete contract literature that control rights should be matched with the party with superior information and ability. There is also evidence that the government uses contract duration to elicit information.

The Labor Market for Managers, Top Management Compensation Gap and Incentive Effect

A Study on the Impact of Different Remuneration of Top Management on Company's Performance:An Empirical Verification Based on Chinese Listed Companies' Data

Effects of CEO Identity on Non-family Managers’ Pay Dispersion in Family Firms: A Social Comparison Perspective

A study on the top management compensation in listed high-tech companies and its effectiveness

Effects Of Compensation Strategy On Psychological Contract - An Empirical Study In China

Is Top Management Compensation Incentive Excessive? Based on Marginal Diminishing Effects and Chinese Private Listed Companies

Excessive Incentive and Corporate Performance: Research Based on Marginal Diminishing Effect and Top Management Team of Chinese Listed Companies

Troubled by unequal pay rather than low pay: The incentive effects of a top management team pay gap

Managerial Labor Market During Institutional Transition: A Study of CEO Compensation and Voluntary Turnover

Political Promotion, CEO Incentives, and the Relationship Between Pay and Performance

Strategic Choices for Sustainable Competitive Advantage, Marketization Degree, and the Executive-Employee Compensation Gap

On the Director Compensation, CEO Compensation and Firm's Performance

An Empirical Study Of The Effects Of Corporate Performance On Managerial Compensation Based On China'S Listed Companies

China's Evolving Managerial Labor Market

A Study on the Compensation Gap among Executives at Chinese Enterprises*

Determinants of Executive Compensation: Empirical Research on Listed-Company in China

WHO WILL BE A STAR CEO---The Source and Influence of Managerial Reputation

Incentives to Move Up the Echelon: Impact of Inter-hierarchical Pay Gaps on Employee Performance

Performance Evaluation Mechanism and CEO Turnover——Evidence Based on Different Ultimate Ownership in China's Lasted Firms

Complementarity and Substitutability of CEO Incentives: Theory and Evidence from Chinese State-Owned Enterprises

Could Executive Compensation Incentive Enhance the Efficiency of Enterprise Resource Allocation? An Empirical Study from China