Abstract:THEORY: Although medical students are exposed to a variety of emotions, the impact of emotions on learning has received little attention so far. Shame-provoking intimate examinations are among the most memorable events for students. Their emotions, however, are rarely addressed during training, potentially leading to withdrawal and avoidance and, consequently, performance deficits. However, emotions of negative valance such as shame may be particularly valuable for learning, as they might prompt mental rehearsal. We investigated the effect of shame on learning from the perspective of cognitive load theory.HYPOTHESES: We hypothesized that (a) training modality determines state shame, (b) state shame directly affects the quality of a clinical breast examination as one example of a shame-provoking exam, and (c) students who experience shame during training outperform those who just discuss the emotion during subsequent performance assessments.METHOD: Forty-nine advanced medical students participated in a randomized controlled, single-blinded study. After a basic, low-fidelity breast examination training, students were randomized to further practice either on a high-fidelity mannequin including a discussion of their emotions or by examining a standardized patient's real breasts. Last, all students conducted a breast examination in a simulated doctor's office. Dependent variables were measures of outcome and process quality and of situational shame.RESULTS: Students training with a standardized patient experienced more shame during training (p < .001, d = 2.19), spent more time with the patient (p = .005, d = 0.89), and documented more breast lumps (p = .026, d = 0.65) than those training on a mannequin. Shame interacted with training modality, F(1, 45) = 21.484, p < .001, η<sup>2</sup> = 0.323, and differences in performance positively correlated to decline in state shame (r = .335, p = .022).CONCLUSIONS: Students experiencing state shame during training do reenact their training and process germane load-in other words, learn. Furthermore, altering simulation modality offers a possibility for educators to adjust the affective component of training to their objectives.

The Education of Shame:What Can Be Done and What Cannot Be Done

Research on the Academic Shame and Its Implications for Education

Shame and Indignation: in the Perspective of Phenomenological Ethics

Let University Student Grow Up Healthily to Receive Education in a Sense of Shame

As a Person and Respect for Others——The Human Being Point of Sense of Shame Education

Shame Research: Concept, Structure and Assessment

Psychological Mechanism Resulting from Sense of Honor and Disgrace and Its Educational Significance

A Sense of Shame as the Salvation of Bottom-line Ethic

The Analyst's Shame

Using shame to extend Martin Conway's self-memory system

Overcoming Shame: A Positive Psychology Perspective

Shame in Medical Education: A Randomized Study of the Acquisition of Intimate Examination Skills and Its Effect on Subsequent Performance

A theoretical review on the role of positive emotional classroom rapport in preventing EFL students’ shame: A control-value theory perspective

Prologue: Shame: Sources and Trajectories

The Effect of Shame on Anger at Others: Awareness of the Emotion-Causing Events Matters

Similarities and Differences of Shame Experiences between Chinese and American College Students

The Structure of Shame among College Students and Questionnaire Setting

The evolution of shame and guilt

The Relationship Between Guilt and Shame——from the perspective of counterfactual thinking

The Co-construction of Shame in the Context of Poverty: Beyond a Threat to the Social Bond

Shame in the Everyday Experience of Poverty1