Prologue: Shame: Sources and Trajectories

Allison Merrick,Daniel Goldin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07351690.2024.2331963
2024-06-05
Psychoanalytic Inquiry
Abstract:At that first signal of shame, I know that something is very wrong in my world, and I have a sinking feeling that that something is me. As the "most deeply personal of emotional experiences" (Nathanson, Citation 1992 , p. 21), shame makes its claim to the "whole self'" (Lewis, Citation 1971 , p. 40) while at the same time depending for its existence on the gaze of the other. Shame in its most extreme form is marked by an "implosion of the self" (Laing, Citation 1960 , p. 46): one physiologically collapses. One becomes as small as is possible. One bows one's head. One turns one's body in on itself. One averts one's eye. One longs to evaporate and yearns "not, as people say, to sink through the floor, but rather ... that the space occupied by me should be instantaneously empty" (Williams, Citation 1993 , p. 89).
psychology, psychoanalysis
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is **the origin of shame and its influence and treatment methods in psychotherapy**. Specifically, the article explores the following aspects: 1. **Definition and manifestation of shame**: - Shame is a profound emotional experience. It involves an individual's comprehensive self - evaluation and depends on the gaze of others (Laing, 1960). Extreme forms of shame can lead to "self - implosion", that is, the individual feels small, lowers their head, avoids eye contact, etc. (Williams, 1993). 2. **Recursiveness of shame**: - Shame can be self - superimposed, forming the phenomenon of "recursive shame", that is, an individual feels further shame because of feeling shame (Morrison, 2011). This recursiveness may cause both patients and therapists to be trapped in the cycle of shame. 3. **Social contagion and avoidability of shame**: - Shame has strong social contagion and is easily transmitted between people (Bromberg, 2006). Therefore, shame is often avoided or ignored, and it is even difficult to touch upon during the process of psychotherapy. 4. **Theoretical challenges of shame**: - Shame triggers a series of unpleasant emotional reactions (such as shame, emptiness, embarrassment, etc.), and these emotions convey a common message: hide oneself and avoid exposure (Rycroft, 1968). This makes shame an elusive emotion that requires in - depth research. 5. **The development process of shame**: - Goldin and Posner's research shows that shame begins to form in infancy. Infants will experience shame when they lose contact with their caregivers (Goldin & Posner, 2024). With the development of language ability, shame becomes more complex, involving the split between the past and present selves. 6. **Manifestations of shame in different contexts**: - The article also explores the manifestations of shame in different cultural and social contexts, for example, the impact of racialized shame on the relationship dynamics between black and white people (Alleyne, 2024). 7. **Moral and social values of shame**: - Merrick explored whether shame has instrumental value, that is, whether it can play a positive role in the social and educational fields (Merrick, 2024). She pointed out that although shame may have some positive effects, its universality and comprehensiveness characteristics make it necessary to introduce alternative perspectives in clinical practice. Through these discussions, the paper aims to provide a comprehensive framework for understanding shame and provide theoretical support and practical guidance for psychotherapists in dealing with shame.