Abstract:Previous theories have established the mental model activation of processing different types of conditionals, stating that counterfactual conditionals expressing events that contradict known facts (e.g., "If it had rained, then they would not go to the park.") are considered to trigger two mental models: (1) a hypothetical but factually wrong model (e.g., "rain" and "did not go to the park") and (2) a corresponding real-world model (e.g., "did not rain" and "went to the park"). This study aimed to investigate whether pragmatic factors differentially influence readers' comprehension and distinction between counterfactual and hypothetical conditional sentences in Mandarin Chinese. Participants were required to read and judge the comprehensibility of Chinese hypothetical and counterfactual conditionals, which were different in temporal indicators (past vs. future temporal indicators) in the antecedent. Different polarities (with vs. without negators) and different moving directions (different directional verbs: lai2 [come] vs. qu4 [go]) in the consequent were also manipulated. Linear mixed-effects models (LMEM) revealed that hypothetical conditionals (with future temporal indicators) were more comprehensible than counterfactual conditionals (with past temporal indicators). The semantic similarities within the subordinate clause revealed future temporal indicators had higher lexical-semantic co-occurrence than past indicators, suggesting that temporal indicators impact comprehension partly through lexical semantics in the premise, and hypothetical conditionals are more easily processed. However, the semantic similarity analysis of the main and the subordinate clauses showed no effect of temporal indicators, suggesting that lexical-semantic co-occurrence across clauses may not substantially contribute to the distinction between hypothetical conditionals and counterfactual conditionals. In conclusion, this study offers insights into the comprehension of Chinese conditional sentences by shedding light on the pragmatic factors influencing the activation of different mental models.

Towards Conditional Conventionality

On Conventional Context Elements in Cognitive Pragmatic Inference

Using the Visual-World Paradigm to Explore the Meaning of Conditionals in Natural Language

Going Forth and Drawing Back: an Intensional Approach in Nonmonotonic Inference.

Pragmatic Commitments to Naturalized Epistemology

Effects of Semantic and Pragmatic Factors on Preschool Children’s Negation-Triggered Inferences on Possible Alternatives

Negation and Free Choice Inference in Child Mandarin

(Core) Common Ground Once More: Response to Liu and Liu

Exploring Pragmatic Factors on the Logical Relationships of Conditional Reasoning: A Study of Counterfactual and Hypothetical Conditionals

On the Rationality that Presupposition Exists in Direct Inference

On the Inference of Presumptive Meanings

Conventionality determines the time course of indirect replies comprehension: An ERP study

On the Transitivity of Logical Consequence without Assuming Monotonicity

Towards Presumptive-knowledge-based Interpretation of Discourse

A Logical Consequence Informed by Probability

The Interdependence Between Generative Syntax and Pragmatics:An Initial and Tentative Exploration

A Radial Category Approach to IF-Conditionals

Monotonicity in Logic and Language: Second Tsinghua Interdisciplinary Workshop on Logic, Language and Meaning, TLLM 2020, Beijing, China, December 17-20, 2020, Proceedings

Default Reasoning:Function Realization of the Cognitive Context

On Some Weakened Forms of Transitivity in the Logic of Conditional Obligation

A Cognitive Semantic and Pragmatic Account of the Constraints on Chinese Topic Constructions