Abstract:The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is considered to be the natural way to realize decision making with pairwise comparisons of alternatives. Within the framework of the AHP model, the full process of forming comparison matrices is considered as an indivisible whole; and the irrational and uncertain behavior of decision makers has been identified and highlighted. In practice, the process of comparing alternatives is complex, especially when the number of alternatives is large. In this study, we propose a sequential modeling of wise comparison process for alternatives, which subsumes the typical AHP model as a special case. A new mathematical framework based on the leading principal submatrices is formed. The process of quantifying priorities of alternatives and the inconsistency-degree process of judgements are proposed to capture the irrationality and uncertainty experienced by decision makers in pairwise comparisons. It is found that the rank preservation is natural according to the comparison process. The acceptable consistency of multiplicative reciprocal matrices is redefined under the principle of weak rationality. A feedback mechanism is proposed to help decision makers avoid irrational behavior and to produce a better outcome of the decision procedure. Some comparisons with the AHP model demonstrate that the proposed model offers a clear way to capture the irrational and uncertain behavior of decision makers when evaluating the importance of alternatives.

Paired-comparison and ranking data:a method of modeling analysis

Models for Paired Comparison Data: A Review with Emphasis on Dependent Data

A Comparison of Formal Methods for Evaluating the Language of Preference in Engineering Design

Paired Comparisons Modeling using t-Distribution with Bayesian Analysis

A Hierarchical Decision Model Based on Pairwise Comparisons.

ROC Analysis for Paired Comparison Data

Model Comparison in Cognitive Modeling

A Comparative Review of Methods for Comparing Means Using Partially Paired Data

P‐31: Theory and Application of Paired Comparison Methods in Display and Lighting Preference Study

Statistical inference for pairwise comparison models

Model Population Analysis For Statistical Model Comparison

The incomplete Analytic Hierarchy Process and Bradley-Terry model: (in)consistency and information retrieval

Bayesian analysis of paired-comparison sound quality ratings

A Sensitivity Analysis Algorithm For The Constant Sum Pair-Wise Comparison Judgments In Hierarchical Decision Models

A Topic Modeling Approach to Ranking

Graphical models for cardinal paired comparisons data

Pairwise Comparison Based Ranking Vector Approach to Estimation Performance Ranking.

Decision Making with a Sequential Modeling of Pairwise Comparison Process.

The many routes to the ubiquitous Bradley-Terry model

On Extending the Bradley-Terry Model to Accommodate Ties in Paired Comparison Experiments

Comparative analysis of the existence and uniqueness conditions of parameter estimation in paired comparison models