Abstract:The rating of items based on pairwise comparisons has been a topic of
statistical investigation for many decades. Numerous approaches have been
proposed. One of the best known is the Bradley-Terry model. This paper seeks to
assemble and explain a variety of motivations for its use. Some are based on
principles or on maximising an objective function; others are derived from
well-known statistical models, or stylised game scenarios. They include both
examples well-known in the literature as well as what are believed to be novel
presentations.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about how to understand and use the Bradley - Terry model from different perspectives and methods. Specifically, the goal of the paper is to collect and interpret various motives for using the Bradley - Terry model. These motives include, but are not limited to, methods based on principles or maximizing objective functions, methods derived from well - known statistical models, and methods based on idealized game scenarios. The paper not only covers known examples in the literature but also contains some formulations considered to be novel.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Collection of Motives**: The main original contribution of the paper lies in collecting various motives for using the Bradley - Terry model, which Bradley (1976) referred to as the "basis of model formulation". By collecting these motives, the paper hopes to provide a useful resource for those who are first exposed to the model and offer a new perspective for those who are familiar with it.
2. **Extended Discussion of the Model**: The paper provides a more detailed discussion than before, especially discussing the Bradley - Terry model in the context of exponential family distributions, which provides a unified theme for many significant motives.
3. **Formalization of Model Simplicity**: The paper proposes an explicit measure to measure the model simplicity in pairwise comparison scenarios and proves that the Bradley - Terry model is the model that maximizes this measure under reasonable constraints.
4. **Relationship with Other Rating Methods**: The paper shows how the rating methods of Wei (1952) and Kendall (1955) and the RPI (Ratings Percentage Index) in American college sports are related to the Bradley - Terry model through the Perron - Frobenius theorem.
### Model Background
The Bradley - Terry model is a statistical model used to rank items according to the results of pairwise comparisons. The model defines the probability \(p_{ij}\) that item \(i\) is superior to item \(j\) in pairwise comparison as:
\[ p_{ij}=\frac{\pi_i}{\pi_i + \pi_j} \]
where \(\pi_i\) is a positive real - number parameter, which can be interpreted as the score of item \(i\), and the higher the score, the greater the "strength" or "value" of the item.
### Applications of the Model
The Bradley - Terry model has been widely applied in multiple fields, including journal citations (Stigler, 1994), college sports (Wobus, 2007), animal behavior (Stuart - Fox et al., 2006), risk analysis (Merrick et al., 2002), wine tasting (Oberfeld et al., 2009), university rankings (Dittrich et al., 1998), font selection (O’Donovan et al., 2014), educational assessment (Pollitt, 2012b), geographical location deprivation (Seymour et al., 2022), etc.
### Paper Structure
The paper divides motives into six categories:
1. **Axiomatic Motives**: Based on the reasonable properties that the model should have, such as the transitivity of probability.
2. **Maximization of Objective Function**: Select the model by maximizing a certain objective function.
3. **Discriminant Process**: Based on Thurstone's discriminant process, discuss the distribution leading to the Bradley - Terry model.
4. **Standard Model**: In other well - known statistical models, the Bradley - Terry model appears as a conditional form.
5. **Game Scenario**: Based on real - life game scenarios, show the intuitive properties of the model.
6. **Quasi - Symmetry and Consistent Estimator**: Discuss the quasi - symmetric model and its relationship with the Bradley - Terry model.
Through these classifications, the paper aims to show the wide application and attractiveness of the Bradley - Terry model in various settings.